650 Years of Arson in Historic Buildings

At around six in the morning on 2 February 1829, choristers crossing the yard at York Minster noticed sparks rising from the cathedral roof.

The night before, a man had sat through evensong, hidden in the building when the doors were locked, and set fire to the choir. By the time the fire was out, the medieval choir stalls, the bishop’s throne, the pulpit and the great organ were gone.

He had even warned them. In the days before, he had left threatening placards on the Minster railings, signed with his initials and his address.

Arson in historic buildings is not new. It’s one of the oldest threats our heritage faces, and it’s still the biggest identified cause of heritage fires today. I’ve traced it through 650 years of British history, from a medieval palace to a Black Country pub. The motives change. The lessons don’t.

Contents

The Savoy Palace, 1381

The Savoy Palace stood between the Strand and the River Thames. It was the London home of John of Gaunt, the king’s uncle and the most powerful man in England. The historian John Stow later wrote that there was none in the realm to compare with it in beauty and stateliness.

In the summer of 1381, England rose up against a new poll tax. Rebels from Kent, led by Wat Tyler, marched from Canterbury to Blackheath and into London. Many blamed John of Gaunt for the tax.

On 13 June 1381, they reached the Savoy. According to accounts of the time, they destroyed everything inside, pounding precious metals with hammers and throwing tapestries into the river. Then they burned what was left of the building. Gaunt himself was safe in the north, negotiating with the Scots.

The Savoy was never rebuilt as a palace. The London Museum notes that the site later became the Savoy Hospital, founded by Henry VII.

The Savoy shows the first and oldest motive for arson in historic buildings. Fire as protest. A building can be targeted not for what it is, but for who or what it represents.

The man hanged for the Great Fire, 1666

Shortly after midnight on Sunday 2 September 1666, fire broke out at Thomas Farriner’s bakery in Pudding Lane. The Gazette, the official public record, says the fire started because he failed to properly put out his oven. Over the next four days, it destroyed around 80% of the old City of London, including Old St Paul’s Cathedral and 87 parish churches.

London wanted someone to blame. Robert Hubert, a watchmaker from Rouen in France, confessed to starting the fire deliberately. His story made little sense. He first said he’d started the fire in Westminster, which the fire never reached. Historians now believe he wasn’t even in the country when it began.

It didn’t matter. Hubert was tried, convicted and hanged at Tyburn in October 1666. As the British Library puts it, he was a troubled outsider who was wrongly blamed and executed.

One historian has suggested another reason the verdict suited people. Tenants who’d lost everything could be freed from paying rent and repairs if the fire was caused by enemy action. A foreign arsonist was convenient.

Hubert is in this story for a reason. He shows that “arson” isn’t always the right answer, and that rushing to blame someone can be as damaging as the fire itself. We’ll meet the same lesson again, more than 350 years later.

John the Painter, 1776

James Aitken was born in Edinburgh in 1752. He trained as a painter, which gave him the name that history remembers him by. John the Painter.

During the American War of Independence, he set out to cripple the Royal Navy by burning its dockyards. After a failed attempt at Plymouth, he arrived in Portsmouth in December 1776 carrying homemade incendiary devices. On 7 December, he set three of them in the dockyard rope house and slipped away. The flames gutted the building. He went on to start fires in Bristol before he was caught.

The National Archives tells the full story. He was tried at Winchester and, on 10 March 1777, hanged at Portsmouth from the mizzenmast of HMS Arethusa, raised at the dockyard gate so as many people as possible could watch. His was the only execution for arson in the history of the Royal Dockyards.

Aitken shows the second motive. Arson as sabotage. Fire used deliberately to damage an enemy, an organisation or a cause.

Jonathan Martin and York Minster, 1829

Back to the choristers and the sparks.

Jonathan Martin was born in 1782 in Northumberland. He was a religious fanatic with a history of mental illness, and he’d recently escaped from an asylum. On 1 February 1829, he attended evensong at York Minster, where he became upset by a buzzing sound from the organ. He hid in the cathedral after the service, set fire to the choir, and escaped through a window.

His placards gave him away. He was caught near Hexham on 6 February and tried at York Castle that March. If the jury found him sane, he would hang. It took them just seven minutes to decide he was of unsound mind. He spent the rest of his life in an asylum in London.

The damage was enormous. The choir was rebuilt over the following years, but the great choir and its organ were never accurately reconstructed, and very little record of how they looked survives. Irreplaceable craftsmanship was simply gone.

The fire also changed how the Minster was protected. According to York Minster’s own account, a watchman was appointed to keep watch day and night afterwards. That watchman became today’s Minster Police. It’s one of the earliest examples I know of a historic building changing how it was managed because of arson.

Martin shows the third motive. Arson driven by mental illness or belief. And he shows something just as important. He was inside the building legitimately, as a worshipper, when he decided to hide.

The suffragette arson campaign, 1912 to 1914

The largest organised arson campaign against British buildings was run by militant suffragettes of the Women’s Social and Political Union. Between 1912 and August 1914, they used arson and bombs to press the government to give women the vote. The Suffragette newspaper itself claimed more than 300 arson and bomb attacks in 1913 and 1914.

Churches were a key target. Historic England explains that the importance of churches to their communities at the time made them obvious targets. At St Anne’s in Aigburth, Liverpool, a Grade II* listed church, a night-time fire destroyed the pulpit and choir stalls and seriously damaged a new organ. In Buckinghamshire, the National Archives holds a 1913 press photograph of the burned organ at Penn Church.

Kitty Marion and Clara Giveen

Kitty Marion was born in Germany and came to England in 1886, aged 15. She became an actress, and then one of the most active arsonists of the campaign. By 1913, according to the London Museum, she was suspected of five arson attacks, including burning down the St Leonards home of Arthur du Cros MP in Sussex.

In June 1913, four days after the death of Emily Wilding Davison at the Epsom Derby, Marion and fellow suffragette Clara Giveen set fire to the grandstand at Hurst Park racecourse in Surrey, near Hampton Court Palace. The damage was put at between £7,000 and £12,000. On 3 July 1913, Marion was sentenced to three years and 21 days in prison.

She later wrote that she “would much rather have had the vote than do this sort of thing to get it”.

Wargrave, 1 June 1914

Closer to home, the parish church of St Mary at Wargrave in Berkshire was set on fire in the early hours of 1 June 1914. The Berkshire Record Office records that postcards accusing the authorities of torturing women were found near the church. The Wargrave Local History Society notes that suffragette messages were left by the people who did it.

The fire destroyed almost everything. The Historic England list entry records that the church, originally built in the 13th century, burned down in 1914, reputedly by suffragettes, leaving only the west tower of 1635, the walls and the north doorway. It was rebuilt in 1916 and is now Grade II* listed. The same night, the arsonists went on to attack a house in Windsor. The Windsor Local History Group puts the scale in context: 107 buildings were set on fire by suffragettes in the first seven months of 1914 alone.

The campaign stopped when war broke out in August 1914. Historians still debate whether the militancy helped or harmed the cause. What isn’t in doubt is the damage to historic buildings. The suffragettes chose their targets carefully. Many were empty at night, such as churches, pavilions, grandstands and unoccupied houses. That pattern still holds today.

Capel Aberfan, 2015

Capel Aberfan is a chapel built in 1876 in the Welsh village of Aberfan. In October 1966, after the spoil tip disaster that killed 144 people, 116 of them children, the chapel was used as a mortuary. After the disaster, the Queen gave the chapel an organ.

In the summer of 2015, the chapel was set on fire. The person responsible was a volunteer cleaner. As ITV News Wales reported, he had keys to the chapel because of his cleaning role. He let himself in, set fire to a dust sheet and walked home. The roof caught light and quickly collapsed.

The fire caused more than £500,000 of damage and destroyed the £40,000 organ given by the Queen. The court heard he had a long fascination with fire and got a thrill from seeing the fire and rescue service arrive. In February 2016, he was given a ten-year extended sentence to protect the public.

Capel Aberfan is one of the clearest modern examples of a risk that runs right back to York Minster. The person with the keys. Most arson prevention focuses on keeping intruders out. This fire was started by someone who was trusted to be inside.

The Derby church fires, 2020

In the autumn and winter of 2020, a series of deliberate fires hit schools and churches across Derby. St Matthew’s Church in Darley Abbey and St Paul’s Church in Quarndon were both badly damaged.

Then, on 3 December 2020, fire gutted All Saints’ Church in Mackworth. It was a 14th-century, Grade I listed church. As Premier Christian News reported, the fire was so severe that the roof collapsed.

The fires were set by a teenager, who admitted them in court and was given a hospital order in 2022. Even his own defence lawyer acknowledged the “colossal damage to the cultural fabric of Derby”.

Grade I is the highest level of protection a building can have. Only a small fraction of listed buildings in England hold it. None of that protection could stop one person with a source of ignition and an empty building at night.

The Star Inn and the arson that wasn’t, 2021

The Star Inn at Harome, in North Yorkshire, is a thatched, Michelin-starred pub. In November 2021, its thatched roof caught fire, causing more than £2 million of damage.

A local man was charged with arson. But in early 2024, before the case reached trial, the prosecution accepted the defence’s expert evidence. As the Whitby Gazette reported, the fire had been caused by accident. Flames from a metal candle bucket under a bench outside the pub had caught cigarette ends thrown down around it. The fire spread into dry ivy, up the wall and into the thatch. The judge recorded a not guilty verdict and praised the defence’s detailed and convincing report.

The Star Inn is the modern Robert Hubert. A historic building burned, someone was blamed, and the real cause was ordinary carelessness. It’s a reminder that proper, expert fire investigation matters, both to clear the innocent and to learn the real lesson. Here, the lesson was about candles, smoking and thatch, not arsonists.

The Crooked House, 2023

The Crooked House near Himley in Staffordshire was one of the most famous pubs in Britain. The building dated from the 18th century and became a pub around 1830. Mining subsidence had left one end of the building almost four feet lower than the other. Visitors came from all over the world to roll marbles “uphill” along the bar.

In July 2023, the pub was sold by Marston’s. Around two weeks later, on the night of 5 August 2023, it was gutted by fire. Less than 48 hours later, its remains were demolished, before the cause of the fire had been established and without the council’s permission.

Staffordshire Police said it was treating the fire as arson. Its investigation led to the arrest of six people on suspicion of arson-related offences, all released. In February 2026, police sent a file of evidence to the Crown Prosecution Service. As ITV News Central reported in June 2026, no decision had been made on whether anyone would be charged. Nobody has been convicted of anything, and nobody should be presumed guilty.

In February 2024, South Staffordshire Council served an enforcement notice requiring the building to be rebuilt as it was. The owners appealed, and the council has said it can’t enforce the notice until the criminal investigation is over. Campaigners saved around 25,000 of the original bricks, which are being kept in locked containers.

The Crooked House teaches two lessons. First, heritage isn’t only about listed buildings. The Crooked House was not listed, but it was loved, and its loss caused national outrage. Second, once a building is gone, the evidence often goes with it. Whatever caused the fire, demolishing the remains within two days made it far harder for anyone to establish the truth.

What 650 years of arson in historic buildings teaches us

Line these cases up, and the same motives appear again and again.

  • Protest. The Savoy in 1381 and the suffragette campaign of 1912 to 1914. Buildings attacked for what they stood for.
  • Sabotage. John the Painter in 1776. Fire used as a weapon.
  • Mental illness and obsession. Jonathan Martin in 1829, and the fascination with fire described in the Capel Aberfan case.
  • Opportunity. Empty buildings at night, from Wargrave to Mackworth.
  • The wrong answer. Robert Hubert in 1666 and the Star Inn in 2021. Fires blamed on arson that weren’t.

The modern figures back up what history shows. Research by Simon Kincaid at Sheffield Hallam University, in his 2022 paper Fire prevention in historic buildings, includes data attributing 43% of fires in historic buildings to arson. Historic England’s research for 2019 found deliberate fire was the largest identified cause of the more than 1,000 fires in England’s historic environment that year. And the specialist church insurer Ecclesiastical has reported that arson is the most common cause of church fires, with 129 arson claims between 2010 and 2015.

In short, arson is consistently the single biggest identified cause of fires in historic buildings. I’ve written more about the wider picture in my article on heritage building fire risk.

How to protect a historic building from arson

The good news is that arson in historic buildings is one of the most preventable causes of fire. Almost every measure below would have made a difference in at least one of the cases in this article.

Control the keys

York Minster and Capel Aberfan both show the risk from people who are legitimately inside. Keep a register of who holds keys and alarm codes. Get keys back when roles end. Check the building is empty when you lock up, including towers, vestries, cupboards and roof spaces.

Secure empty and quiet buildings

Arsonists choose buildings that are empty at night. Make sure doors, windows and access hatches are secure. Consider security lighting and CCTV. If a building is vacant for any length of time, it needs a specific plan. Historic England’s fire advice includes guidance on arson risk reduction, produced with fire and rescue services.

Take away the fuel

Don’t give an arsonist anything to use. Keep wheelie bins, rubbish, pallets and building materials well away from walls and doors, ideally locked away. Consider a letterbox with a fire-resistant container behind it.

Detect fires early

The York Minster fire burned all night before anyone noticed. Automatic fire detection linked to a monitoring centre raises the alarm in minutes, even when the building is empty. In a historic building, detection in roof spaces and voids matters most, because fire can spread there unseen.

Stop fire spreading

Once a fire is set, what decides the outcome is how fast it spreads. Compartmentation means dividing a building into sections with fire-resisting walls, floors and ceilings, so a fire is held back while help arrives. In historic buildings it’s often missing or full of holes. A compartmentation survey finds the gaps. My fire compartmentation guide explains how it works.

Manage the everyday risks too

The Star Inn fire wasn’t arson at all. Candles, smoking areas and outdoor heaters near thatch, timber or ivy are a real risk. Your fire risk assessment should cover them.

Plan for the worst

Have a salvage plan that lists your most important objects, who will save them and where they’ll go. Keep photographs, drawings and inventories off site. After a fire, protect what’s left and let the fire and rescue service and police investigate before anything is cleared. My article on what the Windsor Castle fire teaches owners of historic buildings explains how to write a salvage plan.

Getting help

I carry out fire risk assessments and compartmentation surveys for churches, listed buildings and historic properties across London and the South East. A good fire risk assessment for a historic building looks at arson as seriously as any other risk. My small in-house team and I don’t subcontract our work, and we don’t carry out remedial works, so our advice is independent.

If you’re responsible for a historic building and want to know how well it’s protected against arson, call me on 01276 300351 or email office@esifiresafety.co.uk.

Frequently asked questions

What is the most common cause of fires in historic buildings?

Where a cause is identified, arson is consistently the largest. Research by Simon Kincaid at Sheffield Hallam University includes data attributing 43% of fires in historic buildings to arson, and Historic England’s 2019 figures show deliberate fire as the biggest identified cause.

Who set fire to York Minster in 1829?

Jonathan Martin, a religious fanatic with a history of mental illness. He hid in the cathedral after evensong on 1 February 1829 and set fire to the choir. A jury found him of unsound mind, and he was sent to an asylum rather than hanged.

Did suffragettes burn down churches?

Yes. Churches were among the targets of the suffragette arson and bombing campaign of 1912 to 1914. St Mary’s Church in Wargrave, Berkshire, was burned down on 1 June 1914, reputedly by suffragettes, and rebuilt in 1916. St Anne’s in Aigburth and the church at Penn in Buckinghamshire were also damaged.

Was the Great Fire of London started deliberately?

No. It started in Thomas Farriner’s bakery in Pudding Lane. A French watchmaker, Robert Hubert, falsely confessed to starting it and was hanged in 1666, but historians believe he wasn’t even in the country at the time.

What happened to the Crooked House?

The 18th-century pub near Himley was gutted by fire on 5 August 2023 and demolished less than 48 hours later without permission. Police treated the fire as arson and arrested six people, all released. As of 2026, no charging decision had been made. The council has ordered the building to be rebuilt.

Does listed status protect against arson in historic buildings?

No. Listing protects a building from unauthorised changes, not from fire. Grade I listed All Saints’ Church in Mackworth was gutted by arson in 2020. Protection from arson comes from good security, early detection, fire separation and good management.

How can I protect a church from arson?

Control who has keys, check the building is empty when you lock up, keep bins and combustible materials away from walls, fit automatic fire detection linked to a monitoring centre, and make sure your fire risk assessment covers arson specifically.

Picture of Jamie Morgan <h5>MIFSM MIFPO MSFPE MIET</h5>

Jamie Morgan

MIFSM MIFPO MSFPE MIET

Jamie Morgan is the founder and Principal Consultant at ESI: Fire Safety. With more than 25 years’ experience across fire safety, electrical engineering and technical compliance, he helps building owners and managers work out what needs attention first and what will work day to day. His work spans fire risk assessments, fire strategies, compliance reviews and DSEAR assessments, backed by hands-on experience designing and implementing life safety systems and electrical safety management.

Growing up around the timber-framed cottages and oast houses of rural Kent gave Jamie a lasting interest in historic and heritage buildings. He brings that interest to his work with churches and listed properties, finding ways to improve fire safety while preserving the features that give them their character.

Jamie holds a Level 6 Diploma in Fire Risk Assessment and a Level 5 qualification in Fire Engineering Design. That combination helps him explain how a building’s design affects fire risk, why a recommendation matters and what it means for the people who use the building. You can check his Intermediate registration on the National Fire Risk Assessors Register.

Jamie keeps up with developments in the profession through his memberships of the Institute of Fire Safety Managers, the Society of Fire Protection Engineers, the Institute of Fire Prevention Officers, the British Fire Services Association and the Institution of Engineering and Technology, which he joined in 2007. He also holds supporter membership of the Institute of Heritage Building Conservation and membership of Society for the Protection of Ancient Buildings.

Tags :

Share :

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Telegram

Related Articles

Speak to a fire safety consultant

Planning a fit-out, need a fire risk assessment or working through a compliance issue?

Bring your plans or questions and we’ll talk through what your project needs.