Of all the Sussex church fires I’ve researched, the one at St Paul’s in Brighton was found in the most ordinary way. Just before 9am on 23 December 2010, two days before Christmas, the church warden, John Burdett, went to open up St Paul’s on West Street. Workmen were due to lay new tiles.

When he opened the door, he found the church full of smoke. Brighton and Hove News reported that four fire engines came from Preston Circus. East Sussex Fire and Rescue Service’s watch manager, David Washington, said that, given the heavy smoke, the fire was believed to have been burning for some time before anyone reported it.

Nobody knew. The church had been burning, quietly, while it was locked and empty. That’s the story behind many church fires in Sussex, from a great medieval cathedral to small village churches. I’ve gathered the ones I could verify, and each has something practical to teach anyone who looks after a church today.

Contents

The risk today

Fires in historic buildings aren’t rare in Sussex. A year after the Notre Dame fire in Paris, the Sussex Express looked at heritage fires across East Sussex alone. It found seven in the previous year, including a hotel in Eastbourne, a listed pub and two former school buildings in Lewes.

Churches face all the same risks as other historic buildings, plus some of their own. They’re often empty for most of the week. They have large, open roof spaces. They’re full of timber, fabric, paper and candles. And many are deliberately left open so that anyone can come in and pray.

Chichester Cathedral, 1114 and 1187

Chichester Cathedral had barely been finished when it first burned. It was dedicated in 1108, and on 5 May 1114 a fire is said to have consumed both the cathedral and the city. The Victoria County History suggests that the damage was fairly limited and the church was soon repaired, largely with the help of King Henry I.

The second fire, in 1187, was far worse. It burned out the cathedral and destroyed much of the city, including the bishop’s palace and the canons’ houses. The cathedral’s timber roof was lost, and the stonework was badly damaged.

What happened next is one of the earliest examples of fire protection in an English building. When Bishop Seffrid rebuilt the cathedral, he didn’t put back the wooden ceiling. Instead, the nave was covered with the stone vault you can still see today. Timeref records that he decided the wooden roof should be replaced by stone vaulting, and the repaired cathedral was rededicated in 1199.

Today we’d call that passive fire protection. That’s the part of a building’s fire safety that’s built into its structure, like fire-resisting walls, floors and ceilings, rather than equipment that has to switch on, like an alarm or a sprinkler. A stone vault doesn’t burn. It puts a fire-resisting layer between the people and treasures below and the timber roof above. Eight centuries later, the same thinking lies behind fire compartmentation, which I’ve explained in my fire compartmentation guide.

St Andrew’s, West Dean, 1934

St Andrew’s in West Dean, north of Chichester, was badly damaged by fire in 1934. Sussex Parish Churches records that the fire destroyed practically all of the interior, including the font. A stained glass window from 1901 was probably lost too.

Two things survived. The 18th century west tower came through, and so did a bronze effigy of William James by the sculptor Goscombe John. The architect Frederick Etchells rebuilt the inside of the church, and it was finished in 1935.

West Dean shows a pattern that runs through almost every church fire. The walls and tower usually survive. What’s lost is the interior, the fittings and the things people have given to the church over generations.

St Mary Magdalene, Whatlington, 2010

Whatlington is a small village near Battle. A church has stood there since before the Norman Conquest, and the present building dates from the 13th century.

Shortly before 4.30pm on Thursday 15 July 2010, fire broke out in the organ loft in the west gallery. The Bexhill Observer reported that when the west window collapsed, high winds drove the flames through a void in the roof space. The church was locked, and nobody was inside.

Six crews from Battle, Bexhill, Hastings and Broad Oak stopped the fire spreading into the vestry and tower, and the walls stayed standing. But the roof was destroyed and the church was left structurally unsafe. The organ, worth between £50,000 and £60,000, was completely destroyed. East Sussex Fire and Rescue Service first estimated the damage at around £100,000, though the church treasurer, Hilda Aplin, said that might not even cover the roof.

There were small mercies. The altar, pulpit, lectern and font were damaged by fire, debris and water, but could be restored. With firefighters watching over them, members of the parochial church council were allowed back inside to retrieve important documents.

And there was a surprise when the repair work began. When the new roof was finished two years later, it turned out that although the fire had destroyed the pine boarding inside the roof and blown the tiles off, the medieval roof frame had largely survived. The roof now looks much as it would have done in medieval England.

That weekend was the church’s patronal festival, the celebration of the saint the church is named after. The congregation refused to let the fire stop it, and held a moving evensong in the churchyard beside their fire-damaged church.

St Paul’s, Brighton, 2010

Back to St Paul’s on West Street, five months after Whatlington. When John Burdett opened the doors on 23 December 2010, the fire had probably been burning overnight.

Crews spent about an hour tackling it, then ventilated the building. The damage was mainly smoke. The pulpit was untouched, but a grand piano nearby was destroyed. The church warden said it was fortunate the damage was confined to a fairly small area.

St Paul’s was lucky. A fire that burns unseen all night, in a locked building, can easily become a fire that destroys everything. It’s one of the strongest arguments for automatic fire detection that sends the alarm to a monitoring centre, so a fire is reported in minutes rather than the next morning.

St Barnabas, Bexhill

St Barnabas was the first major Anglican church built in modern Bexhill, consecrated in 1891. One Monday afternoon, shortly after 3pm, a fire broke out in the church library in the north west corner of the building.

The Bexhill Observer reported that crews came from Bexhill, Hastings, Pevensey and Battle. Firefighters went inside, but the flames had already spread into the roof, and they had to pull back. The roof space couldn’t be reached from inside. In the end, an aerial ladder platform from Hastings reached up to the roof ridge, and its powerful water jet blew the tiles off so that enough water could be brought onto the fire.

The library was gutted and part of the roof was severely damaged. Police treated the scene as a crime scene, and a later report said the fire was probably arson. The churchwarden, John Hastwill, called it a very sad day for St Barnabas.

Bexhill is a textbook example of why roof spaces matter. Once a fire is in a roof void that firefighters can’t get into, the only way to fight it is often from outside and above, and that takes time.

St Michael’s, Lewes

St Michael’s on Lewes High Street is the only church still standing within the old town walls. At about 2pm one Monday in August, someone piled paper and books on a chair in a room beneath the bell tower and set them alight.

The Mid Sussex Times reported that the owner of a neighbouring shop saw smoke billowing from the church and raised the alarm. East Sussex Fire and Rescue Service put the fire out quickly, and there was no structural damage. The smoke took a few days to clear.

The parish priest, Father David Broad, said it was very shocking. But he was clear that the church wouldn’t stop welcoming people. “Openness is more important than any fears we may have,” he said.

That’s a view many church wardens share, and it’s a fair one. An open church is part of what a church is for. The answer isn’t to lock everything away. It’s to think about what’s left lying around, where, and who’s keeping an eye on it. A pile of books under a timber bell tower is exactly the kind of thing a fire risk assessment should pick up.

The former Convent of the Holy Child Jesus, St Leonards, 2026

The most recent fire in this article happened only four months ago. On the evening of Thursday 9 July 2026, East Sussex Fire and Rescue Service was called to the former Convent of the Holy Child Jesus on Magdalen Road in St Leonards. The site had been empty for some time.

Dense smoke could be seen across the town. The Sussex Express reported that eight fire engines attended at the height of the fire, with relief crews from across East Sussex working through the night. Police are treating it as arson. Reports say the Grade II listed chapel itself was not affected.

The convent closed as a school decades ago and later fell into disrepair. Empty historic buildings like this are among the most vulnerable there are. Nobody is there to notice a problem, and they attract people who shouldn’t be inside.

What Sussex church fires have in common

Lay these Sussex church fires side by side and some clear patterns appear.

Fires in locked churches burn unseen

Whatlington was locked and empty. St Paul’s in Brighton probably burned overnight before anyone found it. The St Leonards convent was empty. A church that’s closed for most of the week can have a fire burning for hours before anyone notices. Automatic fire detection, linked to a monitoring centre, gives you that warning even at night.

Roof voids are where fires get away

At Whatlington, the wind drove the fire through a void in the roof. At Bexhill, firefighters couldn’t get into the roof space and had to attack it from outside. Old church roofs are usually large, open and full of dry timber, with nothing to stop a fire spreading along them.

Organs are a hidden risk

The Whatlington fire began in the organ loft. Organs have electric blowers and motors, often tucked away inside big timber cases in parts of the church nobody visits. Make sure the organ’s electrics are checked as part of its regular maintenance.

Arson often targets what’s left lying around

At Lewes, books were piled up and set alight. At Bexhill, the fire began in the library. Paper, books, hymn books, leaflets and fabric are easy to set fire to. Think about what’s left out when the church is open, and where.

Stone protects what’s beneath it

After 1187, Chichester replaced its wooden ceiling with a stone vault. It’s one of the oldest examples of building fire protection into a structure in England. Most smaller churches can’t do that, but the principle matters. Anything that slows a fire’s spread buys time to get people out and to save what’s inside.

Walls survive, interiors don’t

West Dean’s tower survived, and Whatlington’s walls stood. In almost every church fire, what’s lost is the inside: the roof, the organ, the furnishings and the treasures.

More than a building

It’s easy to count church fires in pounds. £100,000 at Whatlington, plus an organ worth up to £60,000. But that’s never the whole story.

A community loses its heart

A village church is often the oldest building in the village and the one that holds its memories. Whatlington has had a church on the same site since before 1066. When it burned, the congregation didn’t give up. They held their patronal evensong in the churchyard that same weekend, beside the blackened building.

When a church burns, the services, weddings, funerals, christenings, concerts and groups all have to find somewhere else to go, sometimes for years.

History that can’t be rebuilt

You can rebuild a roof. You can’t rebuild the past.

Chichester’s Norman wooden ceiling was gone for ever in 1187. West Dean lost its font and an Edwardian window. Whatlington lost its organ. Every old church holds things that exist nowhere else: glass, carvings, memorials, embroidery, registers and the marks left by the generations who worshipped there.

What survives is often what someone planned for

There’s hope in these stories too. Whatlington’s medieval roof frame came through and was restored. West Dean’s bronze effigy survived. Chichester’s rebuilding gave it the stone vault that still protects it today. And at Lewes and Brighton, quick action meant there was very little to put back at all.

The difference between losing everything and saving what matters most is rarely luck. It’s a fire found early, a building that slows it down, and people who know what to save first.

How to protect your church

Places of worship come under the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005. The responsible person, usually the churchwardens and the parochial church council, must make sure there’s a suitable and sufficient fire risk assessment. Here’s where I’d start in any historic Sussex church.

  • Make sure your fire risk assessment is current and carried out by someone who understands historic buildings.
  • Consider automatic fire detection linked to a monitoring centre, especially in roof voids, towers, organ lofts and vestries.
  • Have the electrical installation inspected regularly, including the organ’s blower and wiring, and act on the findings.
  • If your church is left open, think about what’s left out. Keep books, paper, leaflets and fabric tidy and away from candles and timber.
  • Report and record every incident of vandalism, small fires or break-ins, and review your security after each one.
  • Keep bins and combustible rubbish well away from the walls.
  • Control any hot work, such as lead roofing or paint stripping, with a written permit and a fire watch afterwards.
  • Put out all candles when you lock up, and keep candle stands away from curtains, hangings and paper.
  • If your church or a building on your site is empty or between uses, keep it secure, check it regularly and keep the fire protection working.
  • Keep a photographic record of the building and its treasures, stored away from the church.
  • Write a salvage plan that sets out what to save first, who will do it and where items will go, and share it with East Sussex or West Sussex Fire and Rescue Service.
  • Keep copies of registers and important documents off site.
  • Review your insurance values so they reflect the real cost of rebuilding a historic church.

For practical advice on preventing arson, Ecclesiastical’s guidance for churches is a good place to start. For salvage and emergency planning, my article on fire safety in historic buildings and what Windsor Castle teaches covers it step by step.

Getting help

I carry out fire risk assessments for churches, halls and historic buildings across East and West Sussex, from Chichester and Brighton to Lewes, Hastings and the villages in between. My small in-house team and I don’t subcontract our assessments, and we don’t carry out remedial works, so the advice we give has no strings attached.

If you’re responsible for a church and you’d like to talk about its fire risk assessment, call me on 01276 300351 or email office@esifiresafety.co.uk.

Frequently asked questions

Do churches need a fire risk assessment?

Yes. Places of worship are covered by the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005, so the responsible person must make sure a suitable and sufficient fire risk assessment is carried out and kept under review. For most Church of England churches, that responsibility sits with the churchwardens and the parochial church council.

What causes most Sussex church fires?

The fires in this article show a mix of causes. St Barnabas in Bexhill and St Michael’s in Lewes were deliberate. Whatlington began in the organ loft, and the cause of the Brighton fire wasn’t known at the time. Nationally, Ecclesiastical Insurance, the specialist church insurer, says arson is the most common cause of fires in churches.

What is passive fire protection?

It’s the part of a building’s fire safety that’s built into its structure, such as fire-resisting walls, floors, ceilings and doors, rather than equipment that has to switch on. It works by slowing the spread of fire and smoke. When Chichester Cathedral replaced its wooden ceiling with a stone vault after the fire of 1187, it was an early example of the same idea.

Can church organs cause fires?

Yes. Organs have electric blowers, motors and wiring, often hidden inside large timber cases in parts of the church nobody visits. The Whatlington fire in 2010 began in the organ loft. Have the organ’s electrics checked as part of its regular maintenance, and include the organ in your fire risk assessment.

Should we keep our church open?

Many churches choose to stay open, and there are good reasons for that. But an open church needs thought. Keep combustible material such as books and paper tidy and away from candles and timber, make sure someone checks the church regularly, and report anything suspicious. Your fire risk assessment should take into account whether the church is left open and unsupervised.

What is a church salvage plan?

It’s a written plan that sets out which objects in the church matter most, the order they should be removed in if there’s a fire, who will do it, what equipment they need and where items will be taken. It should be shared with your local fire and rescue service and kept up to date.

Picture of Jamie Morgan <h5>MIFSM MIFPO MSFPE MIET</h5>

Jamie Morgan

MIFSM MIFPO MSFPE MIET

Jamie Morgan is the founder and Principal Consultant at ESI: Fire Safety. With more than 25 years’ experience across fire safety, electrical engineering and technical compliance, he helps building owners and managers work out what needs attention first and what will work day to day. His work spans fire risk assessments, fire strategies, compliance reviews and DSEAR assessments, backed by hands-on experience designing and implementing life safety systems and electrical safety management.

Growing up around the timber-framed cottages and oast houses of rural Kent gave Jamie a lasting interest in historic and heritage buildings. He brings that interest to his work with churches and listed properties, finding ways to improve fire safety while preserving the features that give them their character.

Jamie holds a Level 6 Diploma in Fire Risk Assessment and a Level 5 qualification in Fire Engineering Design. That combination helps him explain how a building’s design affects fire risk, why a recommendation matters and what it means for the people who use the building. You can check his Intermediate registration on the National Fire Risk Assessors Register.

Jamie keeps up with developments in the profession through his memberships of the Institute of Fire Safety Managers, the Society of Fire Protection Engineers, the Institute of Fire Prevention Officers, the British Fire Services Association and the Institution of Engineering and Technology, which he joined in 2007. He also holds supporter membership of the Institute of Heritage Building Conservation and membership of Society for the Protection of Ancient Buildings.

Tags :

Share :

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Telegram

Related Articles

Speak to a fire safety consultant

Planning a fit-out, need a fire risk assessment or working through a compliance issue?

Bring your plans or questions and we’ll talk through what your project needs.