Do You Automatically Need a Full Compartmentation Survey With a Fire Risk Assessment?

Your fire risk assessment recommends a full compartmentation survey, potentially costing thousands of pounds. But is that level of investigation necessary, or could a more targeted inspection identify the problems without unnecessary expense and disruption?

Imagine you’re responsible for a commercial building containing several businesses.

The ground floor has a warehouse and workshop, there’s office accommodation above, and the building has undergone several refurbishments over the years.

You’ve arranged a fire risk assessment, and the report arrives with a recommendation for a full compartmentation survey.

You obtain a quotation and discover that the work could involve several days on site, access to occupied offices, opening ceiling voids and potentially removing sections of walls to examine concealed construction.

The cost is considerably more than you expected.

Naturally, you want to understand why.

Did the assessor find evidence of defective fire-stopping? Are there concerns about the walls separating the workshop from the offices? Has something happened to suggest that the original fire-resisting construction is no longer suitable?

Or has a full compartmentation survey simply been recommended because that’s what the assessor includes in every report?

A full compartmentation survey isn’t automatically required every time a fire risk assessment is undertaken.

In April 2026, the Fire Industry Association (FIA) addressed this very issue, warning that unnecessary recommendations for comprehensive compartmentation surveys were creating significant expenditure for building owners.

However, there’s an equally important point. Some buildings have serious compartmentation defects, particularly where they’ve been altered repeatedly or different businesses share the same structure.

Failing to investigate genuine concerns can leave occupants exposed to significant risks.

So when is a full compartmentation survey justified, what should your fire risk assessment already have considered, and how can you avoid paying for unnecessary work without overlooking important safety problems?

What Is Fire Compartmentation, and Why Does It Matter?

Fire compartmentation is part of a building’s passive fire protection.

It involves dividing a building into separate areas using fire-resisting walls, floors, doors and other construction intended to restrict the spread of fire and smoke.

The purpose is to help contain a developing fire, protect escape routes and reduce the risk to people elsewhere in the building.

But compartmentation doesn’t serve exactly the same purpose in every type of premises.

In an office building, fire-resisting walls may protect the escape staircase, separate plant rooms or prevent smoke spreading between different floors.

In a factory, compartmentation might separate production areas from offices, protect an escape route or contain a particular process presenting additional fire hazards.

A warehouse may rely on fire-resisting construction to separate storage areas, offices or other parts of the operation. Depending on its design, compartmentation can also contribute to property protection and business continuity.

In a mixed-use building, the construction separating a restaurant from flats above may be fundamental to protecting people sleeping in the residential accommodation.

And in a block of flats operating a stay-put strategy, effective separation between individual flats and communal areas is particularly important.

The common principle is that fire-resisting construction needs to perform the function the building’s fire safety strategy depends upon.

A hole through a compartment wall, an unsealed service penetration or a defective fire-resisting floor could allow smoke and flames to spread beyond the area in which they should have been contained.

That’s why compartmentation needs to be considered during a fire risk assessment.

But considering compartmentation and commissioning a full specialist survey are not necessarily the same thing.

Is a Full Compartmentation Survey a Legal Requirement?

Under Article 9 of the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005, the Responsible Person must ensure that a suitable and sufficient fire risk assessment is carried out.

That assessment needs to consider the precautions required to protect relevant people, including the adequacy of fire-resisting construction where it forms part of the building’s fire safety arrangements.

Article 17 also requires necessary fire safety measures to be subject to suitable maintenance arrangements and kept in efficient working order and good repair.

However, neither provision imposes a blanket requirement for every building to undergo a separate, full compartmentation survey.

In April 2026, the FIA published Mythbuster 31, addressing whether a full compartmentation survey is required as part of a fire risk assessment.

The FIA explains that, unless there’s reason to suspect serious deficiencies in fire-resisting construction or fire-stopping, a sampled, non-invasive inspection will normally be sufficient.

Where further investigation is recommended, there should be specific reasons for concern, and those reasons should be recorded in the fire risk assessment.

We agree with that approach.

The important question isn’t whether a building has undergone the most extensive survey available. It’s whether the assessment has obtained sufficient information to identify relevant fire safety risks and determine whether further investigation is necessary.

What Should a Normal Fire Risk Assessment Already Include?

A fire risk assessment shouldn’t simply assume that walls and floors provide adequate fire resistance because the building looks reasonably modern.

The assessor should consider the visible condition of relevant fire-resisting construction and identify signs of damage, alteration or inadequate fire-stopping.

Depending on the building, this might include examining compartment walls, accessible ceilings, service cupboards, risers and areas where building services pass through fire-resisting construction.

Where suspended ceilings have readily removable tiles, it may be appropriate to lift a representative sample to examine the construction above.

Similarly, opening a sample of accessible service risers may provide useful information about the condition of fire-stopping around cables, pipes and other services.

These are non-invasive inspections because the construction isn’t damaged and any removable panels or tiles can be reinstated afterwards.

The FIA specifically recognises this approach in its April 2026 guidance.

However, the inspection must remain proportionate and practical. Access might be restricted, some construction may be concealed, and opening certain areas may require specialist arrangements.

Those limitations should be recorded.

A fire risk assessor shouldn’t claim to have verified construction that hasn’t been examined.

Equally, the absence of visible defects doesn’t provide a guarantee that every concealed wall, floor and service penetration is satisfactory.

Where the evidence raises legitimate doubts, further investigation may be necessary.

What About Compartmentation in Offices and Commercial Buildings?

Office buildings can accumulate compartmentation defects surprisingly quickly.

An office that was originally open-plan might now contain meeting rooms, individual offices, additional kitchens and altered escape routes.

Over time, contractors may have installed new data cabling, air conditioning, electrical supplies and other building services.

Every time a service passes through a fire-resisting wall or floor, the opening needs suitable fire-stopping.

Consider a three-storey office where the protected staircase is enclosed by fire-resisting walls.

An IT contractor installs new network cables between floors, passing through the wall above a suspended ceiling.

If the opening isn’t properly sealed afterwards, smoke from a fire could bypass the protection intended for the staircase.

The Home Office’s fire risk assessment guidance for offices and shops specifically identifies damaged fire-resisting construction, service penetrations and concealed voids as matters requiring consideration.

The guidance doesn’t expect every ordinary office fire risk assessment to become a structural survey.

It does, however, expect the assessor to consider the building’s construction and recognise potential routes for fire and smoke spread.

If an initial inspection identifies several defective penetrations, further investigation may be justified.

But if the building’s construction is straightforward, accessible areas appear satisfactory and there is no particular reason to suspect serious hidden deficiencies, a full intrusive survey may be unnecessary.

Do Factories and Warehouses Need Compartmentation Surveys?

Factories, workshops and warehouses present different challenges.

These buildings may contain large open spaces, high-level storage, production machinery, plant rooms and industrial processes that introduce significant fire hazards.

Some rely on fire-resisting construction to separate hazardous activities, protect offices or provide safe escape routes.

Others have large open compartments where the fire strategy may depend on a combination of construction, detection, suppression and management arrangements.

A full compartmentation survey isn’t automatically necessary simply because a building is industrial.

But the fire risks, construction and history of alterations may provide good reasons for further investigation.

Factories and Workshops

Imagine a manufacturing premises with a fabrication workshop, paint storage area, production space and first-floor offices.

The fire safety strategy may rely on fire-resisting construction separating particular activities from occupied office accommodation.

Over time, contractors install compressed-air pipework, electrical distribution cables, extraction ductwork and other services through the separating walls.

If those openings aren’t protected correctly, the intended compartmentation may be compromised.

Where flammable liquids, combustible dusts or other significant hazards are present, the consequences of inadequate separation can be particularly serious.

The fire risk assessment should consider the relevant hazards and existing fire precautions. Some activities may also require a separate DSEAR assessment.

Where the initial inspection identifies questionable penetrations, damaged fire-resisting construction or uncertainty about the separation of higher-risk areas, a targeted compartmentation investigation may be appropriate.

Warehouses and Storage Buildings

Warehouse layouts can change considerably during the building’s working life.

High-level racking may be introduced, mezzanines constructed, office accommodation extended or new mechanical handling systems installed.

In some buildings, fire-resisting partitions separate offices from storage or production areas. Others incorporate fire-resisting enclosures around plant rooms, protected staircases or particular hazards.

There may also be concerns about concealed cavities, service penetrations or the suitability of insulated panel construction.

The Home Office’s fire risk assessment guidance for factories and warehouses provides specific guidance for these types of premises.

The appropriate investigation should consider the building’s actual construction and fire safety arrangements.

For example, if a warehouse mezzanine has been added without clear documentation of the supporting fire protection, further assessment may be needed.

But that doesn’t automatically mean every wall and floor throughout the entire warehouse requires intrusive investigation.

The scope should be determined by the concerns identified.

What About Multi-Tenant and Mixed-Use Buildings?

This is an area where compartmentation can become particularly complicated.

Consider a building containing ground-floor retail units, a restaurant, offices on the first floor and residential flats above.

Several occupiers share the same building, but they may have very different fire hazards, occupancy patterns and evacuation arrangements.

The restaurant may operate commercial cooking equipment, while residents in the flats above could be sleeping when a fire occurs.

The fire-resisting construction between these occupancies may be fundamental to protecting the building.

Now imagine the restaurant undertakes a refurbishment and installs new extraction ductwork through the floor separating it from the offices or flats above.

Who checks whether the penetrations have been adequately protected?

The commercial tenant may have arranged the work, but the landlord may be responsible for the structure. A managing agent may control the common parts, while another contractor maintains the building’s fire safety systems.

This is where the cooperation and coordination requirements under Article 22 of the Fire Safety Order become important.

Different Responsible Persons need to cooperate where their activities or responsibilities affect fire safety elsewhere in the building.

The Home Office’s guidance for people with fire safety duties specifically recognises the need to coordinate fire safety measures in multi-occupied premises.

A compartmentation investigation may be justified where there is evidence that alterations within one tenancy could have compromised the protection of another.

But the investigation should be properly scoped.

If the concern relates to ductwork passing through the floor above one restaurant, it may be sensible to investigate that construction first.

If further inspections reveal similar deficiencies throughout the development, a wider survey may then be appropriate.

The existence of multiple tenants doesn’t automatically justify a full compartmentation survey. But it does make proper coordination of building alterations and fire safety responsibilities particularly important.

When Is a Full Compartmentation Survey Justified?

There are circumstances where a comprehensive survey is entirely reasonable.

The important thing is that the recommendation should arise from identifiable concerns, rather than simply appearing in every fire risk assessment.

One example is where the initial inspection reveals multiple defective service penetrations.

If an assessor lifts several ceiling tiles and discovers that cables have been installed through a compartment wall without suitable fire-stopping, it’s reasonable to question whether similar defects exist elsewhere.

Another is where a building has undergone extensive alterations without reliable records.

Repeated tenant fit-outs, changes of use, new mechanical services and structural alterations can all create opportunities for compartmentation to be compromised.

The building’s fire strategy is also important.

In residential blocks operating a stay-put strategy, the separation between flats and common areas is fundamental to fire safety.

In hospitals and care homes, compartmentation may support progressive horizontal evacuation, allowing occupants to move into another protected area.

Where occupants may have difficulty evacuating quickly, defects in fire-resisting construction can have particularly significant consequences.

A previous fire can also provide evidence of a problem. If smoke spread into areas where the building’s fire strategy assumed it would be contained, that provides a legitimate reason for further investigation.

In each case, the scope of the survey should reflect the concerns identified and the potential consequences.

What’s the Difference Between Non-Invasive and Intrusive Surveys?

This is important because it affects the cost, disruption and planning required.

A non-invasive compartmentation survey examines reasonably accessible fire-resisting construction without damaging it.

That might involve lifting removable ceiling tiles, opening service risers, examining accessible voids and inspecting visible fire-stopping.

An intrusive survey goes further by opening up construction that cannot otherwise be inspected.

It may involve removing sections of plasterboard, exposing concealed wall or floor construction or opening service enclosures.

That work needs careful planning because the affected construction must subsequently be reinstated appropriately.

There may also be additional safety considerations.

In older buildings, intrusive work may require suitable asbestos information or a refurbishment asbestos survey before materials are disturbed. The Health and Safety Executive’s guidance on asbestos surveys explains these responsibilities.

Intrusive investigations may also require access arrangements, isolation of services and coordination with occupants.

This is why they shouldn’t be recommended casually.

Where they are necessary, the scope should be agreed in advance, including who is responsible for opening up and reinstating the construction.

Are Type 1, Type 2, Type 3 and Type 4 Assessments Relevant to Commercial Buildings?

You may have heard fire risk assessors referring to Type 1, Type 2, Type 3 and Type 4 assessments.

These categories come from the guidance for purpose-built blocks of flats. They describe whether the assessment covers common parts only or extends into flats, and whether destructive investigation is included.

A Type 1 assessment covers the common parts non-destructively, while Type 2 adds sampled destructive inspection.

Type 3 extends the non-destructive inspection into flats, and Type 4 combines inspection of flats and common parts with sampled destructive investigation.

The government’s Fire Safety in Purpose-Built Blocks of Flats guide explains these assessment types and identifies Type 1 as normally sufficient for most purpose-built blocks unless there is reason to suspect serious deficiencies.

The older guide should be read alongside subsequent legislation and current guidance.

However, these Type 1–4 categories shouldn’t be automatically applied to offices, factories, warehouses or mixed-use commercial developments.

For those buildings, the inspection scope should be described according to the premises, their fire strategy and the level of investigation necessary.

Should You Survey the Entire Building or Just the Areas of Concern?

A sensible investigation should normally begin with the evidence already available.

Imagine an office building where defective fire-stopping has been found in one service riser.

Rather than immediately opening up every compartment wall, it may be more proportionate to inspect comparable risers and adjacent construction.

If the additional investigation reveals similar defects, the scope can be expanded.

The same approach can apply to factories, warehouses and mixed-use developments.

If an industrial building has questionable fire separation around one high-risk process, begin by establishing whether that separation is suitable.

If a restaurant refurbishment has potentially compromised the floor above, investigate the affected floor construction and relevant service routes.

Where the findings suggest widespread problems, a comprehensive survey may be justified.

This is a more useful approach than automatically recommending the most extensive survey available.

However, sampling has limitations. Finding no defects in the sampled areas doesn’t guarantee that every concealed element elsewhere in the building is satisfactory.

The extent of the inspection, access limitations and any remaining uncertainty should therefore be clearly documented.

What Should You Ask If Your Fire Risk Assessment Recommends a Survey?

If your report recommends a full compartmentation survey, it’s reasonable to ask the assessor to explain the findings behind that recommendation.

What evidence suggests the construction may be defective? Which walls, floors or areas are affected? How does the concern relate to the building’s fire strategy?

Could a targeted inspection answer the question, or is there reason to suspect that the problem is widespread?

And does the investigation actually need to be intrusive?

A competent fire risk assessor should be able to explain these matters because the reasons for further investigation should already be documented in the assessment.

If the recommendation appears to be identical to the one made for every other building, without reference to its construction or identified risks, it’s worth asking for clarification.

That doesn’t mean challenging necessary safety work simply to avoid spending money.

It means understanding what you’re being asked to commission and whether the proposed investigation is proportionate.

What Should a Compartmentation Survey Report Include?

If further investigation is necessary, the report needs to provide useful evidence.

It should identify the areas inspected, describe the construction examined and record the defects found.

Photographs and accurate locations are particularly helpful, especially where the remedial works will be undertaken by a separate contractor.

The report should also distinguish between confirmed defects, areas that couldn’t be inspected and matters requiring further investigation.

For example, an unsealed opening through a compartment wall is a confirmed defect.

A concealed section of construction that couldn’t be accessed is an inspection limitation, not automatically evidence of a defect.

Where repairs are required, the recommendations should be proportionate to the significance of the findings.

After remedial work, suitable completion records, photographs and other supporting evidence should be retained.

These records help the Responsible Person demonstrate that defects have been addressed and support future inspections, fire risk assessments and changes in building management.

At ESI: Fire Safety, we consider the relationship between fire risk assessments and compartmentation surveys particularly important. The specialist investigation should provide the evidence needed to understand specific concerns, while the fire risk assessment considers what those findings mean for the safety of occupants.

Don’t Pay for a Full Survey Without Understanding Why

Fire compartmentation is fundamental to protecting escape routes and restricting the spread of fire and smoke.

Where serious defects exist, identifying and correcting them can be essential.

But it doesn’t follow that every office, factory, warehouse, residential block or mixed-use building automatically needs a full compartmentation survey whenever its fire risk assessment is renewed.

A competent assessor should examine the accessible construction, identify relevant concerns and recommend further investigation where the evidence justifies it.

Sometimes that will involve examining a few additional ceiling voids or service risers.

In other circumstances, particularly where defects appear widespread or important fire-resisting construction cannot otherwise be verified, a larger or intrusive investigation may be necessary.

The objective isn’t to spend the least possible money on fire safety.

It’s to make sure that the money is spent on investigations and improvements that genuinely matter.

An unnecessarily extensive survey can waste thousands of pounds. But failing to investigate a serious compartmentation defect could have much greater consequences.

The right approach is proportionate, evidence-led and based on the building’s actual fire risks.

Need Advice About a Compartmentation Survey?

At ESI: Fire Safety, we help landlords, commercial property owners, managing agents, facilities managers and business operators understand whether their existing fire-resisting construction is suitable and when further investigation may be necessary.

Our services include fire risk assessments, compartmentation surveys, fire door inspections and independent fire safety consultancy.

We work with factories, workshops, warehouses, offices, residential blocks and multi-tenant or mixed-use developments.

Our coverage includes Hampshire, Surrey, Berkshire, Sussex, Kent, Oxfordshire and South West London, serving locations such as Gosport, Epsom, Wokingham, Worthing, Rochester, Bicester and Sutton.

If your fire risk assessment recommends a full compartmentation survey and you’re unsure whether the proposed scope is justified, we can review the findings and help establish the appropriate level of investigation.

Where significant defects are suspected, we can advise on targeted inspections, wider surveys and the prioritisation of remedial work.

Our aim is to provide clear, practical advice that addresses genuine fire safety risks without recommending unnecessary expenditure.

ESI: Fire Safety — No Shortcuts in Safety.

Contact ESI: Fire Safety or call 01276 300 351 to discuss your fire risk assessment or compartmentation survey requirements.

This article focuses on fire safety legislation in England and Wales. The appropriate scope of investigation depends on the premises, their fire strategy, available evidence and the risks to occupants.

Picture of Jamie Morgan <h5>MIFSM MIFPO MSFPE MIET</h5>

Jamie Morgan

MIFSM MIFPO MSFPE MIET

Jamie Morgan is the founder and Principal Consultant at ESI: Fire Safety. With more than 25 years’ experience across fire safety, electrical engineering and technical compliance, he helps building owners and managers work out what needs attention first and what will work day to day. His work spans fire risk assessments, fire strategies, compliance reviews and DSEAR assessments, backed by hands-on experience designing and implementing life safety systems and electrical safety management.

Growing up around the timber-framed cottages and oast houses of rural Kent gave Jamie a lasting interest in historic and heritage buildings. He brings that interest to his work with churches and listed properties, finding ways to improve fire safety while preserving the features that give them their character.

Jamie holds a Level 6 Diploma in Fire Risk Assessment and a Level 5 qualification in Fire Engineering Design. That combination helps him explain how a building’s design affects fire risk, why a recommendation matters and what it means for the people who use the building. You can check his Intermediate registration on the National Fire Risk Assessors Register.

Jamie keeps up with developments in the profession through his memberships of the Institute of Fire Safety Managers, the Society of Fire Protection Engineers, the Institute of Fire Prevention Officers, the British Fire Services Association and the Institution of Engineering and Technology, which he joined in 2007. He also holds supporter membership of the Institute of Heritage Building Conservation and membership of Society for the Protection of Ancient Buildings.

Tags :

Share :

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Telegram

Related Articles

Can You Refuse a Fire Safety Inspector Access to Your Premises?

The short answer is no, not in any way that helps you. Fire safety inspectors have legal powers of entry and inspection, and obstructing them or failing to produce records is a separate criminal offence. The more useful question is what an inspection actually asks of you on the day, and how to be ready for it.

Read More »

Speak to a fire safety consultant

Planning a fit-out, need a fire risk assessment or working through a compliance issue?

Bring your plans or questions and we’ll talk through what your project needs.