Your Landlord Says Fire Safety Is Your Responsibility. Your Lease Says Otherwise. Who’s Right?

In a multi-occupied building, landlords, managing agents and tenants can all have fire safety duties. The problem is that those responsibilities don’t always fit neatly together, and important precautions can get overlooked.

Imagine you rent an office on the second floor of a commercial building. You’ve arranged your fire risk assessment, trained your staff and made sure your fire extinguishers are serviced.

Everything appears to be in order.

Then your fire risk assessor asks when the communal fire alarm was last serviced. You don’t know, because the landlord looks after that.

They ask whether the emergency lighting in the shared staircase works. Again, that’s the landlord’s responsibility.

But what happens when your employees need to use that staircase to escape from a fire? Or the communal alarm fails to warn people working in your office?

Can you simply say it’s nothing to do with you?

Not quite.

One of the biggest challenges with fire safety in multi-occupied buildings is that several organisations can have legal duties relating to the same premises. Those duties can overlap, particularly where businesses share escape routes, fire alarms and other fire safety measures.

Whether it’s an office block, shopping parade, business centre or restaurant with flats above, the important question isn’t simply who owns the building. It’s who controls the different areas, what responsibilities they have and how everyone works together.

Who Is Responsible for Fire Safety in a Multi-Occupied Building?

Under Article 3 of the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005, an employer is the Responsible Person for a workplace to the extent that it is under their control.

So, if your business rents an office, shop or workshop and employs people there, your business will normally be a Responsible Person under the legislation.

But that doesn’t mean the landlord has no responsibilities.

Article 5 of the Fire Safety Order also places duties on other people who have control over premises, including those with maintenance, repair or safety obligations under a lease or contract.

Depending on the circumstances, a landlord or managing agent may be a Responsible Person or have other duties arising from their control and contractual responsibilities.

The distinction matters because not everyone involved in managing a building automatically has the same legal status or obligations.

Your lease is an important starting point for identifying who maintains particular parts of the property. However, a lease cannot simply remove statutory duties placed on an employer or another dutyholder by fire safety legislation.

For example, the landlord might maintain the communal staircase, but an employer must still consider whether that staircase provides a suitable escape route for its employees.

The Home Office’s guidance for people with fire safety duties explains that tenants must consider the adequacy of shared fire safety arrangements, even where their landlord is responsible for maintaining them.

You might not be responsible for repairing the equipment, but you can’t ignore a serious defect simply because somebody else owns it.

Does Every Tenant Need a Separate Fire Risk Assessment?

In most multi-occupied commercial buildings, each tenant employer will need a suitable and sufficient fire risk assessment covering its activities and the risks to relevant people.

The landlord or other relevant dutyholder will also need to ensure that appropriate assessment arrangements cover the common parts and shared fire safety measures.

These don’t necessarily have to be entirely separate documents. A coordinated assessment can be appropriate, provided each Responsible Person fulfils its legal duties.

However, a landlord’s assessment of the communal areas doesn’t automatically cover everything happening inside an individual business.

Consider a building with a restaurant on the ground floor, offices above and a shared staircase.

The restaurant has commercial cooking equipment, extraction systems and potential fire hazards associated with its operation. The offices may have comparatively modest fire risks, but their occupants could still be affected by a fire starting downstairs.

The building’s fire safety arrangements must account for both.

It’s no good having the restaurant’s assessment stop at its entrance door while the landlord’s assessment starts in the communal corridor, without either considering the fire separation between them.

Fire doesn’t recognise the boundaries drawn on a lease plan.

That’s why the different assessments need to work together.

What Does Article 22 of the Fire Safety Order Require?

Article 22 of the Fire Safety Order deals specifically with cooperation and coordination between Responsible Persons who share premises or have duties relating to them.

These duties have existed for many years, but changes introduced by Section 156 of the Building Safety Act 2022, which came into force in October 2023, strengthened the requirements.

Responsible Persons must now take reasonably practicable steps to identify other Responsible Persons who share the premises or have duties relating to them.

Where others are identified, they must exchange their names, a UK address for receiving notices and information about which parts of the premises they consider themselves responsible for. They must also keep a record of the required information.

But Article 22 isn’t simply about exchanging contact details.

It requires Responsible Persons to cooperate, take reasonable steps to coordinate their fire safety measures and inform one another about risks arising from their activities.

For example, if a restaurant introduces new cooking equipment that changes the fire risk to the building, that information may need to be shared with the landlord and other affected dutyholders.

Similarly, if the landlord discovers a serious fault with the communal fire alarm, tenants need to know because it may affect their evacuation arrangements.

The Home Office recommends recording these arrangements in writing and ensuring that fire risk assessments across the building complement one another.

Where Do Fire Safety Responsibilities Most Often Get Overlooked?

In our experience, problems frequently arise at the boundaries between areas controlled by different organisations.

A landlord’s assessment might exclude the tenant’s office because it’s separately occupied. The tenant’s assessment might exclude the communal staircase because the landlord maintains it.

Individually, those decisions may seem reasonable.

But who checks the fire door between the office and staircase? Who makes sure alterations inside the tenant’s premises haven’t affected the shared fire alarm? And who checks that contractors installing new cables haven’t damaged the compartment walls?

These are precisely the issues that effective cooperation is intended to address.

Fire Doors Between Tenancies and Common Areas

A fire door separating a tenant’s premises from a shared corridor or staircase may be essential to protecting an escape route.

The landlord might be responsible for repairing the door, while the tenant controls how it’s used.

If the tenant wedges it open, damages the closer or installs unsuitable access control equipment, the intended fire protection could be compromised.

Both parties therefore have an interest in ensuring the door remains effective. The maintenance arrangements should establish who inspects it, who undertakes repairs and how defects are reported.

Fire Alarms That Cross Tenancy Boundaries

Many multi-occupied buildings have a single fire alarm system serving several businesses.

The landlord may arrange maintenance, but detectors, sounders and manual call points could be located inside individual tenancies.

What happens if a tenant installs a suspended ceiling that obstructs a detector, changes the internal layout or refuses access when the engineer arrives for servicing?

The Home Office guidance specifically recognises the need for tenants to cooperate with access for testing and maintenance of shared fire alarm equipment.

The landlord and tenants need clear arrangements for inspections, maintenance access and approval of alterations.

Compartment Walls, Floors and Service Penetrations

Consider a tenant employing an electrician to install new data cables through a wall separating its office from a communal escape route.

The electrician drills several holes, pulls through the cables and leaves without suitable fire-stopping.

The landlord may own the wall, but the tenant’s contractor has compromised its fire resistance.

Similar problems can arise during plumbing, ventilation, electrical and refurbishment works.

These alterations need proper control, including arrangements for approving penetrations through fire-resisting construction and obtaining evidence that suitable fire-stopping has been completed.

Without coordination, defects can remain unnoticed for years.

What About Shops and Restaurants With Flats Above?

Mixed-use buildings can be particularly challenging because commercial and residential occupancies may have different fire safety arrangements.

A ground-floor restaurant might operate a simultaneous evacuation procedure, while the residential accommodation above follows a stay-put strategy.

These procedures don’t necessarily need to be identical, but they must be compatible with the building’s fire strategy and the protection provided.

For example, the residential accommodation may depend on effective fire-resisting separation from the restaurant below.

If a commercial tenant installs extraction ductwork through a compartment floor without suitable fire protection, that could undermine the arrangements protecting residents.

The Fire Safety Act 2021 clarified that, for buildings containing two or more sets of domestic premises, the Fire Safety Order extends to the building’s structure, external walls, common parts and doors between flats and common parts.

The commercial and residential fire risk assessments should therefore consider relevant risks and the arrangements connecting the different occupancies.

The objective isn’t necessarily to impose one evacuation procedure on everybody, but to ensure that the arrangements are suitable and work together.

What Happens When the Landlord and Tenant Disagree?

Disagreements aren’t uncommon, particularly when remedial work is expensive.

The landlord may argue that a defective fire door falls within the tenant’s demise. The tenant may point to a lease clause suggesting that structural repairs are the freeholder’s responsibility.

Meanwhile, the fire door remains defective.

The lease is important for establishing contractual responsibilities, but the statutory duties under the Fire Safety Order also need to be considered.

The first step is to establish the nature of the defect, who has control over the equipment and what the lease or management agreement says about maintenance.

The relevant parties should then agree how the problem will be addressed, including any temporary precautions that may be necessary.

Where cooperation breaks down and a significant fire safety concern remains unresolved, the matter may need to be referred to the enforcing authority.

A disagreement about who pays for repairs shouldn’t leave occupants exposed to an unmanaged fire safety risk.

How Can Landlords and Tenants Make Article 22 Work in Practice?

One practical solution is to establish a written record of the shared fire safety arrangements.

At ESI: Fire Safety, we favour a straightforward fire safety responsibility map, sometimes called an interface map.

This doesn’t need to be complicated. It should identify the important shared systems and building features, who maintains them, who controls their use and how defects or alterations are communicated.

For example, it might establish that the landlord maintains the communal fire alarm, tenants provide access for servicing and no tenant can alter fire alarm devices without proper agreement.

It could also identify responsibilities for shared fire doors, compartment walls, emergency lighting and escape routes.

The evacuation procedures should be coordinated, while recognising that different parts of a mixed-use building may have different, properly designed strategies.

These arrangements should be reviewed when tenants change, refurbishment works begin or significant fire safety issues are identified.

There is also an additional duty under Article 22A, which requires an outgoing Responsible Person to pass relevant fire safety information they hold to the incoming Responsible Person.

This helps maintain continuity when premises change hands.

A new tenant or building owner shouldn’t have to start from scratch trying to establish how the fire safety arrangements operate.

Does Having Separate Fire Risk Assessments Mean the Building Is Safe?

Not necessarily.

A landlord may have a comprehensive assessment of the communal areas, while every tenant has its own assessment covering the activities within its premises.

But if those assessments don’t consider how shared fire safety measures interact, important risks can still be overlooked.

That’s why Article 22 is more than an exercise in exchanging names and addresses.

It requires meaningful cooperation and coordination.

A shared fire alarm, communal staircase, compartment wall or fire door cannot always be managed effectively by looking at one tenancy in isolation.

The most useful fire risk assessments identify those interfaces, explain the responsibilities and highlight where further cooperation or action is necessary.

Because the biggest problem in a multi-occupied building isn’t always that nobody has carried out a fire risk assessment. Sometimes it’s that everybody has one, but nobody has joined them together.

Fire Risk Assessments for Multi-Occupied Buildings

At ESI: Fire Safety, we undertake fire risk assessments and provide practical fire safety consultancy for offices, business centres, commercial premises, mixed-use buildings and residential developments.

We help landlords, managing agents and business occupiers understand their responsibilities under the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005, including the cooperation and coordination requirements of Article 22.

Our approach considers not just individual areas of occupation, but also the shared escape routes, fire alarm systems, compartmentation and other fire safety arrangements connecting them.

We work throughout Surrey, Hampshire, Berkshire, South West London and the wider South East.

If your building has several tenants, conflicting fire risk assessments or uncertainty about who is responsible for particular fire safety measures, we can help establish where the responsibilities sit and what needs to happen next.

ESI: Fire Safety — No Shortcuts in Safety.

Contact ESI: Fire Safety to discuss fire risk assessments and fire safety responsibilities in your multi-occupied building.

This article focuses on fire safety legislation and guidance in England. The Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005 also applies in Wales, although some associated guidance and implementation arrangements differ.

Picture of Jamie Morgan <h5>MIFSM MIFPO MSFPE MIET</h5>

Jamie Morgan

MIFSM MIFPO MSFPE MIET

Jamie Morgan is the founder and Principal Consultant at ESI: Fire Safety. With more than 25 years’ experience across fire safety, electrical engineering and technical compliance, he helps building owners and managers work out what needs attention first and what will work day to day. His work spans fire risk assessments, fire strategies, compliance reviews and DSEAR assessments, backed by hands-on experience designing and implementing life safety systems and electrical safety management.

Growing up around the timber-framed cottages and oast houses of rural Kent gave Jamie a lasting interest in historic and heritage buildings. He brings that interest to his work with churches and listed properties, finding ways to improve fire safety while preserving the features that give them their character.

Jamie holds a Level 6 Diploma in Fire Risk Assessment and a Level 5 qualification in Fire Engineering Design. That combination helps him explain how a building’s design affects fire risk, why a recommendation matters and what it means for the people who use the building. You can check his Intermediate registration on the National Fire Risk Assessors Register.

Jamie keeps up with developments in the profession through his memberships of the Institute of Fire Safety Managers, the Society of Fire Protection Engineers, the Institute of Fire Prevention Officers, the British Fire Services Association and the Institution of Engineering and Technology, which he joined in 2007. He also holds supporter membership of the Institute of Heritage Building Conservation and membership of Society for the Protection of Ancient Buildings.

Tags :

Share :

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Telegram

Related Articles

Speak to a fire safety consultant

Planning a fit-out, need a fire risk assessment or working through a compliance issue?

Bring your plans or questions and we’ll talk through what your project needs.