Your Fire Safety Records Look Fine. Would an Inspector Agree?

You’ve got a fire risk assessment, maintenance certificates and a fire safety folder full of documents. But would they actually demonstrate that your building is being managed safely? Here’s what fire safety inspectors look for, what the latest enforcement figures reveal and how to avoid the mistakes that catch businesses out.

Imagine two fire safety inspectors arrive at your premises and ask to see your fire safety inspection records.

You take them into the office, open the filing cabinet and produce a folder containing your fire risk assessment, fire alarm certificates, emergency lighting reports and staff training records.

Everything is there, neatly organised.

So you’re compliant, right?

Not necessarily.

What happens when the inspector opens the latest fire alarm maintenance report and discovers a fault that was never repaired?

Or finds that the fire risk assessment recommended work to several fire doors, but nobody can produce evidence that the repairs were completed?

Perhaps the emergency evacuation procedure names a fire warden who left the business last year.

Or the building has been refurbished since the last fire risk assessment, but nobody thought to have the changes reviewed.

A building can have an impressive collection of fire safety documents and still have serious compliance problems.

That’s because a fire safety inspector isn’t simply checking whether you’ve got the right paperwork.

They’re looking for evidence that the necessary fire precautions exist, remain effective and are being properly managed.

And the latest national enforcement figures provide an interesting insight into where businesses most often get things wrong.

What Does a Fire Safety Inspector Actually Check?

A fire safety inspection normally involves two closely related activities: examining the building and reviewing the records that demonstrate how fire safety is being managed.

The Home Office’s guidance on fire safety enforcement explains that enforcing authorities examine fire safety records alongside an inspection of part or all of the premises.

The inspector might examine escape routes, fire doors, alarm systems and other precautions before asking for the relevant records.

Alternatively, they may begin by reviewing the fire risk assessment and use its findings to guide their inspection.

Either way, the documents and the condition of the building need to tell a consistent story.

For example, your fire risk assessment might state that escape routes are checked daily and kept free from obstruction.

But if the inspector finds delivery boxes stored in the protected staircase, they’ll naturally question whether those arrangements are actually working.

Similarly, a maintenance contract might demonstrate that you’ve appointed a competent company to service your fire alarm.

But if the latest report identifies an unresolved fault affecting detection, the inspector will want to establish what action has been taken.

The National Fire Chiefs Council’s fire safety auditing guidance recognises the importance of considering both physical fire precautions and the management arrangements needed to maintain them.

The objective isn’t to find the business with the thickest compliance folder.

It’s to establish whether the Responsible Person is meeting their duties under the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005.

Which Fire Safety Failures Are Most Commonly Identified by Inspectors?

This is where the national figures become particularly interesting.

The National Fire Chiefs Council’s Enforcement Register provides public information about statutory notices issued by fire and rescue authorities.

These include enforcement notices, prohibition notices and alterations notices.

For enforcement notices, the register identifies the articles of the Fire Safety Order or relevant regulations that the authority considers have been breached.

However, the register shouldn’t be confused with a complete record of every deficiency identified during a fire safety audit. It focuses on published statutory notices, and not every unsatisfactory inspection results in formal enforcement.

For a clearer picture of the most frequently identified breaches, we can look at the Government’s Fire Prevention and Protection Statistics for England, April 2025 to March 2026.

Published on 2 September 2026, the figures show that fire and rescue authorities carried out 50,195 fire safety audits during the reporting period.

Of those, 29,909, approximately 60%, received a satisfactory outcome.

That means around four in ten audits were recorded as unsatisfactory.

What Were the Most Frequently Recorded Breaches?

The Government’s figures identify the following as the most frequently breached articles during fire safety audits in England:

Fire Safety Order dutyRecorded breaches, 2025–26
Article 14 — Emergency routes and exits11,286
Article 17 — Maintenance9,727
Article 9 — Fire risk assessment9,271
Article 8 — General fire precautions8,792
Article 15 — Emergency procedures7,955
Article 13 — Firefighting and fire detection7,262
Article 11 — Fire safety arrangements5,240

These are recorded instances of article-level non-compliance during audits, not numbers of prosecutions or individual buildings. One audit can identify breaches of several articles.

Nevertheless, the pattern is revealing.

The most frequently recorded problems concern escape routes, maintenance and the adequacy of fire risk assessments.

And Article 11, covering fire safety management arrangements, was cited 5,240 times, an increase of 25% compared with the previous year.

For business owners and managing agents, the message is fairly straightforward.

Fire safety enforcement isn’t simply about whether you have a fire risk assessment. It’s about whether the necessary precautions are in place, maintained and properly managed.

1. Is Your Fire Risk Assessment Still Accurate?

One of the first documents an inspector may ask for is your current fire risk assessment.

Under Article 9 of the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005, the Responsible Person must ensure that a suitable and sufficient assessment of fire risks is carried out and kept under review.

Since October 2023, the legislation has required Responsible Persons to record their fire risk assessments in full, including all findings, regardless of the number of employees.

The identity of anybody appointed to assist with the assessment or its review must also be recorded.

But producing a recent assessment doesn’t automatically demonstrate that it remains suitable.

Imagine a warehouse that was assessed eighteen months ago.

Since then, a mezzanine has been constructed, additional storage racking has been installed and part of the building has been converted into offices.

The original assessment may have been perfectly reasonable when it was undertaken, but does it still reflect the building?

The same issue arises when new tenants move into a commercial property, a restaurant increases its seating capacity or a business introduces new equipment or working processes.

The inspector may compare what the assessment says with what actually exists.

Where significant changes have occurred, or there’s reason to suspect the assessment is no longer valid, Article 9 requires a review and any necessary revisions.

A fire risk assessment that no longer reflects the building is unlikely to provide a reliable basis for managing its fire safety.

2. Have the Fire Risk Assessment Actions Actually Been Completed?

This is where otherwise well-managed businesses can run into problems.

The fire risk assessment identifies deficiencies and recommends improvements.

But what happens afterwards?

Imagine the assessment identifies five defective fire doors, inadequate emergency lighting in a storeroom and a need for additional staff training.

Six months later, the action plan shows everything as completed.

That’s reassuring, but where is the evidence?

Were the fire doors repaired by a competent contractor? Is there a report identifying the work undertaken? Was the emergency lighting installed and tested? Did employees actually receive the training?

Writing “completed” in a spreadsheet isn’t the same as demonstrating that the necessary work was done.

A good compliance record connects the original finding with the corrective action and appropriate evidence of completion.

That might include contractor reports, inspection records, dated photographs or relevant certificates.

Not every action requires a formal certificate, and an invoice alone doesn’t necessarily establish that work was completed satisfactorily.

However, the records should provide reasonable evidence of what happened.

Where recommendations remain outstanding, there should be a clear explanation of their status, the person responsible and the proposed timescale.

If essential fire precautions are impaired, any necessary temporary measures should also be considered and documented.

The important thing is to demonstrate that findings are being managed rather than forgotten.

3. Do Your Maintenance Records Show That Faults Were Repaired?

Maintenance is one of the most frequently identified areas of non-compliance.

Under Article 17 of the Fire Safety Order, necessary fire safety equipment must be subject to suitable maintenance arrangements and kept in efficient working order and good repair.

That can include fire alarms, emergency lighting, fire doors, smoke control systems, rising mains and other equipment relevant to the building.

An inspector may ask to see maintenance reports and testing records.

But the date on the front of a certificate is only part of the story.

Consider a fire alarm maintenance report showing that an engineer attended in March and identified a defective detector.

The September report identifies the same fault.

Both service visits took place, but the records suggest the defect remained unresolved for six months.

That’s the sort of issue an inspector may investigate.

They may want to know whether the defect affected the necessary protection, whether repairs were arranged and what temporary precautions were considered.

The same principle applies to emergency lighting, fire doors and other equipment.

A maintenance report identifying a defect isn’t evidence that the defect was subsequently repaired.

The accompanying repair records and follow-up testing may be just as important as the original inspection certificate.

4. Are Escape Routes Actually Safe and Available?

Article 14 was the most frequently recorded area of non-compliance during 2025–26.

That’s particularly significant because emergency escape routes are among the most fundamental fire precautions in a building.

Under Article 14 of the Fire Safety Order, emergency routes and exits must remain suitable and available where necessary for the safety of relevant persons.

Doors on emergency routes must be capable of being opened easily and immediately by people who may need to use them.

An inspector will be interested in what actually exists on site.

Are corridors and staircases clear? Can emergency exits be opened without searching for a key? Are fire doors closing properly?

Has additional storage been placed on an escape route since the last fire risk assessment?

Perhaps your housekeeping checklist says the staircase is inspected every morning.

But if the inspector finds delivery cages and cardboard boxes stored there, the paperwork won’t change the physical condition of the escape route.

Records can demonstrate that checks are organised and undertaken, but they don’t replace the need to keep the building safe.

5. Can You Demonstrate That Fire Safety Is Being Managed?

This is where Article 11 becomes particularly important.

Article 11 of the Fire Safety Order requires the Responsible Person to make and give effect to suitable arrangements for planning, organising, controlling, monitoring and reviewing fire safety measures.

Since October 2023, those arrangements must be recorded by all Responsible Persons.

But writing a fire safety policy isn’t enough.

The arrangements have to operate in practice.

For example, your fire safety procedures might state that a designated manager checks the escape routes each morning and that trained fire wardens assist with evacuation.

What happens if the designated manager left the business last year?

Or the employees named as fire wardens no longer work the same shifts?

The inspector may ask staff questions to establish whether the arrangements are understood and implemented.

They may also examine training records, fire drill information and routine inspection logs.

A procedure that exists only in a document isn’t particularly useful if the people expected to implement it don’t know what they’re supposed to do.

That’s why fire safety management needs regular monitoring and review.

6. Are Your Staff Trained and Do They Understand the Procedures?

The legislation doesn’t simply require a business to write down its emergency procedures.

Under Articles 19 and 21 of the Fire Safety Order, employees must receive appropriate fire safety information and training.

That includes understanding the relevant risks, emergency arrangements, escape routes and actions to take when a fire is discovered.

Training must be provided when employees first start work and repeated or updated as appropriate.

An inspector may ask whether staff understand the building’s evacuation procedure.

Do they know where the assembly point is? Can they identify the available escape routes? Who raises the alarm and contacts the emergency services?

If the business has appointed fire wardens, are those people still available and competent for their roles?

Training records provide evidence of what instruction has been given, but the inspector may also want to establish whether the arrangements are understood.

A signed attendance sheet can be useful. It doesn’t necessarily prove that somebody knows how to respond during an emergency.

7. What if Your Building Has Several Responsible Persons?

Multi-occupied buildings introduce additional responsibilities.

A landlord may maintain the communal fire alarm and escape staircase, while individual tenants are responsible for managing the risks associated with their own activities.

Under Article 22 of the Fire Safety Order, Responsible Persons who share premises or have duties relating to them must cooperate and coordinate their fire safety measures.

Since October 2023, they must also take reasonably practicable steps to identify other Responsible Persons, exchange the required contact information and record which parts of the premises they consider themselves responsible for.

An inspector may ask how those responsibilities have been established.

Who maintains the shared fire alarm? Who inspects communal fire doors? How are tenants informed about defects affecting escape routes?

A lease or management agreement may help establish the responsibilities, but the inspector may also want evidence that the parties are cooperating.

A building can have several individual fire risk assessments and still contain gaps if nobody has considered how the shared precautions work together.

What Additional Records Do Residential Buildings Need?

For buildings containing two or more sets of domestic premises, additional fire safety information duties may apply.

Under Article 21A of the Fire Safety Order, the Responsible Person must provide residents with specified information about fire risks, protective measures and relevant dutyholders.

The Fire Safety (England) Regulations 2022 also require applicable fire safety instructions and fire door information to be provided to residents.

These instructions must be supplied to new residents as soon as reasonably practicable and reissued to existing residents at intervals not exceeding twelve months.

It’s sensible to retain copies of the information issued and records showing when it was distributed.

What About Fire Door Checks?

For multi-occupied residential buildings in England where the top storey is more than 11 metres above ground level, Regulation 10 requires quarterly checks of communal fire doors and best-endeavours annual checks of flat entrance fire doors.

The Responsible Person must keep records of the steps taken to undertake the annual flat entrance door checks, including attempts to arrange access where entry wasn’t possible.

These records may be particularly relevant during a fire safety inspection.

An inspector may ask whether the checks have been undertaken and how outstanding defects are being managed.

A list of flat entrance doors marked “not inspected” without evidence of reasonable efforts to arrange access may not demonstrate compliance with the best-endeavours requirement.

For high-rise residential buildings, further duties apply concerning essential firefighting equipment, building plans and other information.

The appropriate records depend on the building and the regulations applying to it.

Can Fire Safety Records Be Kept Digitally?

Yes. There isn’t a general requirement for every fire safety record to be maintained in a paper folder.

Digital records can be entirely appropriate, provided they remain accurate, accessible and properly managed.

Under Article 27 of the Fire Safety Order, authorised inspectors have powers to require relevant records and documents to be produced.

That includes appropriate extracts from information held electronically.

The practical problem isn’t whether records are digital.

It’s whether anybody can find them.

Imagine the person responsible for fire safety is on holiday, and the inspection records are stored in their personal cloud account.

Nobody else has access.

Or the managing agent has changed, but the previous company still holds the maintenance history.

These situations can create unnecessary difficulties during an inspection.

At ESI: Fire Safety, we recommend maintaining a central compliance record that authorised personnel can access when needed.

It doesn’t need to be complicated, but it should bring together the current fire risk assessment, outstanding actions, maintenance reports, training records and relevant fire safety management arrangements.

What Happens if an Inspector Finds Problems?

Not every fire safety inspection results in formal enforcement action.

Where deficiencies are relatively minor and the Responsible Person is willing to address them, the authority may provide advice or issue a non-statutory notification.

More serious or unresolved breaches can lead to formal notices.

The Government’s guidance on enforcement and sanctions explains the range of measures available, including enforcement notices and prohibition notices.

An enforcement notice can require specified breaches to be remedied within a stated period.

A prohibition notice can restrict or prohibit use of premises where the risk to relevant persons is sufficiently serious.

The enforcing authority considers the nature of the deficiencies, the risk to occupants and the circumstances of the Responsible Person when determining the appropriate response.

Cooperation and evidence that problems are being actively addressed can be relevant factors.

However, good records don’t excuse serious defects or make unsafe premises acceptable.

They help demonstrate what arrangements have been made and what action has been taken.

How Can You Prepare Your Fire Safety Records Before an Inspection?

The simplest approach is to look at your compliance records as an inspector would.

Take the latest fire risk assessment and compare it with the building as it exists today. Has the layout changed? Are the same activities taking place, and have occupancy levels increased?

Next, review the action plan.

For each completed recommendation, establish what evidence exists. Where actions remain outstanding, check that they have appropriate priorities, responsibilities and timescales.

Then examine the maintenance reports.

Look beyond the service dates and identify any defects that were reported. Can you demonstrate whether those defects were repaired?

Finally, consider your fire safety management arrangements.

Are the people named in the procedures still working for the organisation? Have employees received appropriate training, and are routine inspections and emergency procedures being carried out?

These checks don’t need to become a major administrative exercise, particularly for a small business.

But they should give you confidence that the records reflect what is actually happening in the building.

Why Do Otherwise Reasonable Buildings Fail Fire Safety Audits?

The national statistics show that many of the most common breaches concern fundamental fire precautions rather than obscure technical requirements.

Escape routes must remain usable. Fire safety equipment needs suitable maintenance. Fire risk assessments need to remain accurate, and emergency procedures must work.

In our experience, problems often develop because individual tasks are undertaken without anybody checking the overall picture.

The fire alarm contractor completes the service, but a reported defect isn’t followed up.

The fire risk assessor produces an action plan, but nobody checks whether the work is completed.

Employees receive training, but the nominated fire wardens leave and aren’t replaced.

Or the building is altered without anybody considering the effect on the original fire safety arrangements.

These aren’t always problems caused by a complete absence of fire safety precautions.

Sometimes the precautions exist, but the arrangements for managing them aren’t sufficiently effective.

The real purpose of fire safety records is to demonstrate that problems are identified, appropriate action is taken and the precautions needed to protect people continue to work.

Would Your Fire Safety Records Stand Up to an Inspection?

A well-organised fire safety file is useful.

But the documents should do more than demonstrate that reports and certificates have been produced.

They should help establish whether the building’s fire precautions remain suitable, whether inspections and maintenance have taken place and whether identified defects have been addressed.

The latest government figures reinforce the importance of getting the basics right.

Emergency escape routes, maintenance and fire risk assessments remain the most frequently recorded areas of non-compliance during fire safety audits.

And effective fire safety management is what connects all three.

The question isn’t whether you can produce an impressive folder when an inspector arrives.

It’s whether the records demonstrate that the building is being managed safely, and whether the condition of the premises supports what those records say.

Need Help Preparing for a Fire Safety Inspection?

At ESI: Fire Safety, we help business owners, landlords, facilities managers and managing agents understand their fire safety obligations and maintain suitable compliance records.

Our services include fire risk assessments, fire safety compliance reviews, fire door inspections, fire alarm consultancy and ongoing fire safety management support.

We work with offices, restaurants, shops, factories, warehouses, residential developments and multi-occupied commercial buildings.

Our coverage includes locations such as Andover in Hampshire, Cobham in Surrey, Sandhurst in Berkshire, Chichester in West Sussex, Folkestone in Kent, Thame in Oxfordshire and Wimbledon in South West London, together with surrounding areas.

If you’re expecting a fire safety inspection, have received a deficiencies letter or simply want to establish whether your records demonstrate ongoing compliance, we can help review the information, identify significant gaps and advise on the next steps.

We can also help you develop practical arrangements for tracking fire risk assessment recommendations, maintenance defects and evidence of completed work.

ESI: Fire Safety — No Shortcuts in Safety.

Contact ESI: Fire Safety or call 01276 300 351 to discuss your fire safety compliance arrangements.

This article focuses on fire safety legislation in England, with the relevant provisions of the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005 also applying in Wales. The enforcement statistics quoted relate to fire safety audits undertaken in England during the year ending March 2026.

Picture of Jamie Morgan <h5>MIFSM MIFPO MSFPE MIET</h5>

Jamie Morgan

MIFSM MIFPO MSFPE MIET

Jamie Morgan is the founder and Principal Consultant at ESI: Fire Safety. With more than 25 years’ experience across fire safety, electrical engineering and technical compliance, he helps building owners and managers work out what needs attention first and what will work day to day. His work spans fire risk assessments, fire strategies, compliance reviews and DSEAR assessments, backed by hands-on experience designing and implementing life safety systems and electrical safety management.

Growing up around the timber-framed cottages and oast houses of rural Kent gave Jamie a lasting interest in historic and heritage buildings. He brings that interest to his work with churches and listed properties, finding ways to improve fire safety while preserving the features that give them their character.

Jamie holds a Level 6 Diploma in Fire Risk Assessment and a Level 5 qualification in Fire Engineering Design. That combination helps him explain how a building’s design affects fire risk, why a recommendation matters and what it means for the people who use the building. You can check his Intermediate registration on the National Fire Risk Assessors Register.

Jamie keeps up with developments in the profession through his memberships of the Institute of Fire Safety Managers, the Society of Fire Protection Engineers, the Institute of Fire Prevention Officers, the British Fire Services Association and the Institution of Engineering and Technology, which he joined in 2007. He also holds supporter membership of the Institute of Heritage Building Conservation and membership of Society for the Protection of Ancient Buildings.

Tags :

Share :

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Telegram

Related Articles

Speak to a fire safety consultant

Planning a fit-out, need a fire risk assessment or working through a compliance issue?

Bring your plans or questions and we’ll talk through what your project needs.