Your Fire Door Looks Fine. But Would It Actually Work?
Your fire doors might look perfectly acceptable, but faulty closers, damaged seals, unsuitable replacement parts and hidden gaps could prevent them from working when they’re needed most. Here’s fire door defects building owners and managing agents should be looking for.
Imagine you’re walking around your office, restaurant or residential building, checking that the fire doors are in good condition.
They look reasonably solid. There are fire door signs, the hinges appear secure and some doors even have certification labels along their edges.
Everything seems fine.
But what happens if one of those doors doesn’t close properly?
Or somebody has replaced a lock, leaving a hole in the door that was never part of its original construction?
Perhaps the door itself is perfectly good, but there’s an unsealed opening above the frame where an electrician installed some cables during last year’s refurbishment.
These might sound like relatively minor issues, but they could affect the door’s ability to prevent fire and smoke spreading through the building.
The problem with fire door defects is that some of the most serious aren’t immediately obvious.
A fire door is much more than a heavy door leaf with a sign attached.
It’s part of a complete fire-resisting assembly, and its performance depends on several components working together.
So what are the most common fire door defects, why do they matter and how do you know whether an existing door needs repairing or replacing?
Why Do Fire Door Defects Matter?
Before looking at individual defects, it’s worth understanding what a fire door is supposed to achieve.
Fire doors form part of a building’s passive fire protection. They’re installed in openings within fire-resisting walls and partitions, helping prevent fire and, where required, smoke from spreading between different parts of a building.
But not every fire door has the same purpose.
Consider the entrance door to a flat in a residential building operating a stay-put evacuation strategy. That door forms an important part of the fire-resisting separation between the flat and the communal areas.
If a fire starts inside the flat, the door helps prevent fire and smoke from entering the shared corridor and affecting other residents.
Now consider a pair of fire doors dividing a long corridor in an office building. Their purpose may be to restrict smoke movement along the escape route, helping protect people evacuating from other parts of the premises.
A fire door protecting an electrical cupboard or service riser performs another function. It helps prevent fire spreading from that enclosure into the surrounding accommodation or through vertical service routes.
These differences matter when assessing defects.
A damaged door closer, for example, may have particularly serious implications where a flat entrance door protects a communal escape route. A defect involving a locked service cupboard door needs to be considered in the context of how that particular door is intended to operate.
That’s why identifying fire door defects shouldn’t simply involve working through a checklist without understanding the building.
The first question should be what the door is protecting and how important it is to the overall fire safety strategy.
What Are the Most Common Fire Door Defects?
The Fire Industry Association’s guidance on what makes a fire door work explains that the performance of a fire door depends on several components, including the leaf, frame, seals, hinges, closer, glazing and other ironmongery.
These components need to be suitable for the door assembly and work together correctly.
In our experience, many defects develop after installation, often through ordinary wear and tear, poorly considered alterations or repairs undertaken without understanding the door’s fire-resisting function.
A locksmith might replace a lock with a different model, cutting additional material from the door. A contractor may install access control equipment without considering the original construction, or somebody might replace a damaged vision panel with unsuitable glazing.
Individually, these alterations can appear quite minor.
But each has the potential to affect the performance of the complete fire door assembly.
Fire Doors That Don’t Close Properly
One of the most common problems is a fire door that no longer closes fully.
The door might close when opened wide but stop a few centimetres short when released from a smaller angle. It may catch on the floor, bind against the frame or fail to overcome the resistance of the latch.
Sometimes the closer has been disconnected because somebody finds the door inconvenient. In other cases, it has simply been adjusted incorrectly or allowed to deteriorate.
A fire door designed to be self-closing needs to return reliably to its closed position. Where a latch forms part of the required closing arrangement, the door should also engage it correctly.
The Home Office’s fire door guidance recommends checking the closing action from both a fully open position and an opening of approximately 15 degrees.
In both cases, the door should close fully into its frame, overcoming any resistance from the latch or floor.
It’s worth remembering that not every fire door requires a self-closing device. Certain service cupboard and riser doors, for example, may be designed to remain locked shut.
The correct arrangement depends on the door’s intended function.
Doors Being Wedged Open
This is another familiar problem.
A fire door is installed to protect an escape route, but somebody decides it’s inconvenient to keep opening it throughout the day.
A wedge appears beneath the door, or a heavy object is placed against it.
The door can no longer close when required, potentially allowing fire and smoke to spread through an opening that should have been protected.
In some premises, keeping particular fire doors open during normal use is entirely reasonable, provided an appropriate automatic release arrangement has been installed.
For example, electromagnetic door holders can retain doors in the open position and release them when the relevant fire detection system operates.
However, the arrangement must be suitable for the building and allow the doors to close correctly.
A wooden wedge isn’t an alternative to a properly designed hold-open system.
Are the Gaps Around Your Fire Doors Too Large?
Gaps around a fire door are important because they can affect its ability to resist fire and smoke.
For modern fire doors, the permitted gaps should be established from the manufacturer’s test evidence and installation instructions.
The Home Office’s guidance identifies gaps greater than 4mm around the head and sides of a door as a potential concern during routine checks.
However, this shouldn’t be treated as a universal installation tolerance for every fire door. Different doorsets may have different requirements, and the gap beneath the door needs separate consideration.
A door that has dropped on its hinges may develop uneven gaps, rub against the floor or fail to close properly.
Sometimes the problem is relatively straightforward to investigate and repair. Other situations may require further assessment, particularly where the door leaf has warped or the frame has become distorted.
Simply adjusting the closer to force a poorly fitting door shut isn’t necessarily an appropriate repair.
The underlying cause of the defect needs to be identified.
For doors intended to restrict smoke movement, the condition of smoke seals and any threshold arrangements is particularly important.
A door may provide some resistance to flames while allowing smoke to pass through gaps that are larger than intended.
In buildings where communal corridors and staircases form protected escape routes, this can have serious implications.
What Happens When Fire Door Seals Are Missing or Damaged?
Fire doors may incorporate intumescent seals, smoke seals or combined products that perform both functions.
Intumescent seals are designed to expand when exposed to heat, helping to close gaps around the door during a fire.
Smoke seals perform a different function. They restrict the movement of smoke around the door edges before temperatures become high enough to activate the intumescent material.
Where these seals form part of the door assembly, they should be present, correctly fitted and maintained in suitable condition.
Damaged, missing, painted-over or poorly fitted seals can affect performance.
However, the absence of modern seals doesn’t automatically mean an older fire door is unsuitable.
Some existing fire doors were constructed to earlier standards and may not have the same arrangements expected on a modern doorset.
Whether those doors remain suitable needs to be considered in the context of their location, original construction where known, condition and the fire safety precautions required for the building.
A competent fire risk assessor should distinguish between a genuine defect and an older design feature that may remain acceptable.
Could a Replacement Lock or Hinge Compromise a Fire Door?
Yes, and this is something that’s easily overlooked.
Fire doors contain components that may need replacement during their working life, including locks, latches, hinges and closing devices.
But these parts aren’t necessarily interchangeable.
A replacement lock might require a larger opening in the door leaf. Different hinges may need new fixing positions, while an incorrectly specified closer could prevent the door from closing reliably.
These alterations can affect the fire-resisting assembly.
For modern doorsets, the manufacturer’s documentation and supporting test evidence should identify the permitted components and configurations.
Where suitable information isn’t available, a competent person should assess the proposed repair or alteration.
A general maintenance contractor or locksmith isn’t automatically competent to undertake every type of fire door modification.
The person carrying out the work needs to understand how their alterations could affect the door’s fire performance.
What About Letterplates, Spyholes and Cat Flaps?
These present similar concerns.
Some fire doors are manufactured with suitable letterplates, spyholes or vision panels as part of their original construction.
However, cutting new openings into an existing fire door can compromise its integrity.
A replacement letterplate or other component needs to be suitable for the particular application and compatible with the door assembly.
Installing an ordinary cat flap in a fire-resisting flat entrance door, for example, may create an opening through which smoke and fire could spread.
The fact that a component fits neatly doesn’t mean it’s appropriate for a fire door.
Where alterations have been undertaken without suitable supporting information, further assessment may be necessary.
Can You Use Ordinary Glass to Repair a Fire Door?
No. Where a fire door incorporates glazing, the glass and its associated installation must be suitable for the intended fire-resisting application.
But the glass itself is only part of the arrangement.
The glazing beads, seals, fixings and dimensions of the opening all contribute to the performance of the assembly.
Replacing a cracked fire-resisting panel with ordinary glass, using unsuitable glazing beads or enlarging an existing vision panel could compromise the fire door.
The Fire Industry Association also highlights an important consideration with older doors.
Older fire-resisting glazing, including some wired glass, may not carry the visible markings expected on newer products.
The absence of a modern marking doesn’t automatically establish that the glazing is unsuitable.
However, damaged, unidentified or questionable glazing should be investigated by a competent person.
A fire door shouldn’t be condemned simply because its components don’t look modern, but genuine defects mustn’t be ignored either.
What About Fire Door Defects Hidden Above the Ceiling?
This is one of the reasons why a fire door shouldn’t be considered in isolation.
Imagine a building where a new fire door has been installed into a fire-resisting compartment wall.
The leaf, frame, hinges and closing mechanism are all suitable, and the door appears to operate correctly.
But above the suspended ceiling, contractors have installed cables and ventilation ductwork through the wall without appropriate fire-stopping.
During a fire, smoke and flames may be able to bypass the door entirely.
The same problem can occur where the joint between the door frame and the surrounding wall hasn’t been adequately fire-stopped.
The government’s Approved Document B guidance explains that a fire doorset should be considered as a complete installed assembly and that the joint between its frame and surrounding construction should be appropriately protected.
This is why fire doors and fire compartmentation need to be considered together.
A fire door inspection examines the condition and suitability of the door assembly. A compartmentation survey may investigate the fire-resisting construction around it, including concealed openings, service penetrations and other potential weaknesses.
Depending on the building and the concerns identified, both types of assessment may be appropriate.
A fire door can be in excellent condition while the wall around it allows fire and smoke to spread.
How Often Should Fire Doors Be Inspected?
Under Article 17 of the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005, necessary fire safety equipment and measures must be subject to suitable maintenance arrangements and kept in efficient working order and good repair.
This applies across relevant premises, not simply residential buildings.
The appropriate inspection programme should reflect the building’s fire risk assessment, the type of doors installed, how frequently they’re used and the likelihood of damage or interference.
A heavily used cross-corridor door in a busy office may need more frequent attention than a door protecting a locked plant room.
However, there are also specific legal requirements for certain residential buildings.
What Are the Fire Door Checking Requirements in Blocks of Flats?
Under Regulation 10 of the Fire Safety (England) Regulations 2022, additional checking duties apply to multi-occupied residential buildings in England where the top storey is more than 11 metres above ground level.
The Responsible Person must arrange checks of communal fire doors at least every three months.
They must also use best endeavours to check flat entrance fire doors at least every twelve months, including their self-closing devices.
Where access to a flat cannot be obtained, the steps taken to arrange access must be recorded.
Importantly, these routine checks aren’t the same as a comprehensive technical fire door inspection.
The Home Office’s revised guidance, published in August 2025, explains that the checks are intended to identify readily observable defects, including damage, unsuitable alterations, excessive gaps and self-closing devices that no longer operate correctly.
They can generally be undertaken by suitably instructed building management staff without requiring a specialist inspector for every routine check.
However, those checks don’t replace the assessment of a door’s inherent fire-resisting suitability where that is necessary.
Where the condition or construction of a door is uncertain, a more detailed inspection by a competent specialist may be appropriate.
Residential buildings below the 11-metre threshold aren’t subject to the same specific quarterly and annual checking intervals under Regulation 10, but general maintenance duties still apply.
Does an Older Fire Door Need Replacing Because It Isn’t Certified?
Not necessarily, and this is an important distinction for landlords and managing agents.
Some older fire doors don’t carry modern certification labels, manufacturer identification or the same components used on contemporary doorsets.
That doesn’t automatically make them unsuitable.
In its Mythbuster guidance on fire door certification, the FIA explains that fire safety legislation doesn’t impose a blanket requirement for existing fire doors to carry certification labels.
The absence of a label alone doesn’t justify replacing an otherwise suitable door.
The Home Office’s revised 2025 guidance makes a similar distinction, explaining that existing flat entrance doors shouldn’t automatically be replaced simply because they don’t meet every modern specification applying to new installations.
The suitability of an existing door needs to be considered in the context of the building’s fire risk assessment.
That includes its location, purpose, condition, likely fire performance and the other fire precautions available.
However, that doesn’t mean every older door should be accepted.
A lightweight replacement door installed where a fire-resisting flat entrance door is necessary, a damaged door leaf or a door with substantial unprotected openings may require repair, further investigation or replacement.
The important distinction is between an existing door that lacks modern documentation and a door that genuinely fails to provide suitable protection.
Replacing every older fire door simply because it doesn’t have a certification label can result in unnecessary expenditure. Ignoring genuine fire door defects because a door has been there for decades can be equally problematic.
Should Fire Door Defects Be Included in the Fire Risk Assessment?
Yes. Where defects affect the building’s fire precautions, they should be considered in the fire risk assessment.
However, their significance depends on the role of the door and the risks associated with the building.
A defective self-closing flat entrance door protecting a communal corridor may be particularly important in a residential building relying on fire compartmentation and a stay-put evacuation strategy.
A damaged door protecting a higher-risk electrical cupboard may also require prompt attention.
Other issues might be relatively minor and suitable for inclusion within a planned maintenance programme.
A competent assessor should consider the defect, the protection the door is intended to provide and the potential consequences if it fails.
The resulting recommendations should be proportionate, with appropriate priorities and timescales.
Where an inspection reveals widespread defects, it may also be necessary to consider whether the building’s existing maintenance arrangements are adequate.
For example, if numerous fire doors have damaged closers, missing fixings or unsuitable alterations, the problem may not simply be individual faulty doors. It could indicate that repairs and modifications haven’t been adequately controlled.
That’s why proper records are useful.
A door register, inspection history and evidence of completed repairs help demonstrate that defects have been identified, managed and rectified.
Can Fire Door Defects Be Repaired, or Must the Door Be Replaced?
Not every fire door defect requires a complete replacement.
Some problems may be capable of repair by a competent contractor, using suitable components and methods supported by the door’s available evidence.
A defective closer, loose hinge or damaged seal may be repairable, depending on the particular assembly.
Other defects may be more serious.
Extensive damage to the door leaf, inappropriate alterations, severe distortion or uncertainty about its construction may make replacement more appropriate.
The decision should be based on the nature of the defect, the door’s intended performance, available technical evidence and whether a suitable repair can be demonstrated.
It’s also important to distinguish between the cost of repairing the current problem and the likelihood of further defects.
An extensively damaged door that’s been repeatedly modified may not represent good value to keep repairing, even where individual repairs are technically possible.
Conversely, replacing a serviceable older door simply because it lacks a modern label may be unnecessary.
A competent inspection should help the building owner understand the available options and avoid spending money on work that doesn’t improve fire safety.
What Can You Check Before Arranging a Fire Door Inspection?
There are several straightforward observations that building managers and occupiers can make without undertaking a specialist technical inspection.
Look at whether the door closes correctly, whether the frame or glazing is visibly damaged and whether any components appear loose or missing.
Check for large or uneven gaps, damaged seals where fitted and signs that the door has been altered.
Consider whether additional locks, letterplates, access control devices or other fittings have been installed since the original door was fitted.
And importantly, ask whether the door is still being used as intended.
A fire door that is routinely wedged open, propped against furniture or prevented from closing because of floor coverings needs attention, even if the leaf itself is in good condition.
These observations are useful for identifying obvious problems, but they don’t establish the full fire performance of the door.
Where there are concerns about its construction, installation or compatibility of components, a competent technical inspection may be required.
Don’t Wait Until a Fire Door Fails to Discover the Defects
Fire doors are often taken for granted.
People walk through them every day, sometimes holding them open with their feet or pushing equipment through without considering the damage that might be caused.
Over time, hinges loosen, closers deteriorate, seals are damaged and alterations are made.
The door might continue to look reasonably solid, but its ability to resist fire and smoke may have changed considerably.
And some of the most important defects aren’t visible without looking beyond the door leaf itself.
That’s why suitable inspections, maintenance and control of alterations matter.
A proper fire door assessment should establish what the door is expected to do, whether the complete assembly remains suitable and what action is necessary where defects are found.
Because the real problem isn’t simply having a defective fire door. It’s believing that the door will protect people during a fire when it may no longer be capable of doing so.
Concerned About Fire Door Defects in Your Building?
At ESI: Fire Safety, we help landlords, managing agents, business owners and facilities managers identify fire door defects and understand their significance within the wider fire safety arrangements of a building.
Our services include fire door inspections, fire risk assessments, compartmentation surveys and independent advice on the suitability of existing fire-resisting construction.
We work with residential blocks, offices, hotels, commercial premises and mixed-use buildings across Weybridge, Chertsey, Addlestone, Egham, Staines-upon-Thames and Ascot, together with surrounding areas.
Whether you’re dealing with doors that won’t close properly, unexplained gaps, damaged glazing, questionable alterations or older doors without certification information, we can help establish whether repair, further investigation or replacement is appropriate.
Our aim is to identify genuine fire safety deficiencies, explain their implications and recommend proportionate action rather than automatically replacing every door that doesn’t match a modern specification.
ESI: Fire Safety — No Shortcuts in Safety.
Contact ESI: Fire Safety or call 01276 300 351 to discuss fire door defects, inspections or fire compartmentation concerns.
This article focuses on fire safety responsibilities in England. The general duties under the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005 also apply in Wales, while the specific fire door checking requirements under the Fire Safety (England) Regulations 2022 apply in England only.