A fire risk assessment has to take a view on compartmentation. It does not, as a matter of course, need a full survey of every wall, floor and service penetration in the building. The skill lies in knowing when a sample is enough and when what the assessor has found justifies going further.
The short answer
No. The Fire Industry Association addressed this directly in its mythbuster series in April 2026. Its position is that a full compartmentation survey is not a requirement of a fire risk assessment. Unless there is reason to expect serious deficiencies, a sampled, non-invasive inspection will normally be enough. The FIA also warned that the opposite belief is spreading and causing significant, unnecessary spending in existing buildings.
We agree. We’d add one caution: “not automatic” does not mean “never”. Both mistakes are expensive. One wastes money on surveys nobody needed. The other leaves a building with hidden breaches that a sensible inspection should have picked up.
What the fire risk assessment should already cover
The law requires the Responsible Person to make a suitable and sufficient assessment of the risks, and to keep fire precautions maintained. For compartmentation, the FIA describes what a normal assessment involves:
- a visual inspection of the visible fire-resisting construction, looking for damage or alterations
- a physical check of easily accessible elements such as walls, ceilings and ducting
- where there are demountable ceilings, lifting a sample of tiles
- opening a sample of service risers, where access is practicable at the time
All of this is non-invasive: nothing is damaged, and anything moved can simply be put back. That is the baseline. An assessor who never lifts a ceiling tile or opens a riser isn’t doing a lighter version of the job. They’re missing part of it.
When doubt is legitimate
The FIA’s test is that any recommendation for further investigation should rest on specific issues that give reason for doubt, and those issues should be recorded in the assessment. In our experience, genuine reasons for doubt usually fall into a few groups.
What the sample shows. If three ceiling tiles along a corridor are lifted and two reveal unsealed cable bundles through the corridor wall, the sample is telling you something. It would be unreasonable to assume the rest of that wall line is fine.
The building’s history. Repeated fit-outs, IT and data upgrades, new mechanical services or a change of use all create penetrations. Where there’s no record that fire-stopping was checked afterwards, the risk of hidden breaches goes up.
Conversions. Buildings converted into flats or offices may never have had the separation the current layout relies on. Age alone is not the trigger. Government guidance on purpose-built flats says a block’s age is not generally enough, by itself, to justify destructive inspection.
The evacuation strategy. The FIA points out that where evacuation is delayed, as with “stay put” in blocks of flats, or where evacuating vulnerable people carries significant risk, as in care homes and hospitals, compartment walls and floors do more of the work. Doubts in those buildings carry more weight.
Unexplained events. Smoke turning up somewhere it shouldn’t have after a previous fire or alarm activation is a reason to look properly.
Proportionate escalation
When there is doubt, the next step should match it. That rarely means jumping straight to a full invasive survey of the whole building. A sensible sequence is:
- Record the specific concern in the fire risk assessment: what was seen, where, and why it matters to the fire strategy.
- Targeted investigation of the affected wall lines, risers or floors, usually non-invasive to begin with.
- A wider non-invasive compartmentation survey, if the targeted work suggests the problem is widespread.
- Intrusive (destructive) investigation, only where the concern involves concealed construction that can’t be judged any other way. It should be scoped to specific locations and planned with making good in mind.
For blocks of flats, the FIA links this to the Type 1 to Type 4 fire risk assessment categories used in government guidance on purpose-built flats. Type 1 covers the common parts only and is non-destructive; the others extend into flats and/or involve destructive inspection. That guidance describes Type 1 as the basic assessment and says it will normally be sufficient for most purpose-built blocks unless there is reason to expect serious deficiencies.
What to ask if you’re given a survey recommendation
If your fire risk assessment recommends a compartmentation survey, you’re entitled to ask:
- What did you actually find, and where?
- Which part of the fire strategy does it affect?
- What scope is proportionate: a specific area, a floor, or the whole building?
- Does it need to be invasive, or would a non-invasive survey answer the question?
A good assessor will answer these readily, because the answers should already be in the report. If the recommendation looks the same as the one in every other report they’ve written, it’s worth asking why.