Of all the Surrey church fires I’ve researched, one begins the way so many do. Just after midnight on Christmas Eve 2007, a woman in Peper Harow, near Godalming, woke to a strange light outside her window. She could see a fire but couldn’t work out where it was coming from. It was the village church.

The evening before, about 150 people had sung carols in St Nicholas’ Church. By the time the fire was out, just before 4am, around 80% of its roof had gone. The vicar didn’t find out until he checked his answerphone at about 8am.

Surrey has lost, nearly lost and rebuilt more historic churches than most people realise. I’ve pulled together every one I could verify, from Croydon in 1867 to Fleet in 2015, just over the county border. Each one teaches something practical about protecting the building you look after.

I’ve used Surrey in its historic sense here, the county as it was before 1965. That takes in Putney, Barnes and Croydon, which were Surrey parishes when they burned.

Contents

Croydon Parish Church, 1867

On the night of Saturday 5 January 1867, the sexton of Croydon’s parish church, Richard Kilmaster, spotted small flames at about a quarter to eleven. Around 45 minutes later, the roof came down.

What happened in between is a lesson in how much can go wrong. According to Inside Croydon’s history of the fire, the town’s water supply was turned off at night. The turncock, the man with the key to turn it back on, had to be woken up at home. When water finally arrived, the hoses delivered little more than a trickle. Frozen slush made the hydrant hard to find, and rivalry between the fire crews slowed things down further.

The losses were enormous. The roof, the organ, the gallery and the stained glass were destroyed, and the archbishops’ tombs inside were damaged. So were the church’s original charters, which went back to Edward I in 1277. Some of the history of the town simply ceased to exist that night. The lectern was one of the few things carried out.

Nobody knows for certain how it started. One theory is that the heating flues ran too close to the roof timbers. The building was insured for £10,800, which turned out to be far too little. Sir George Gilbert Scott rebuilt the church, and it was rededicated on 5 January 1870, three years to the day after the fire. Today it’s Croydon Minster.

Most of those problems sound Victorian. But I still find modern versions of them. A church car park that a fire engine can’t get into. Nobody quite sure where the nearest hydrant is. Precious records kept in a cupboard in the vestry. Insurance values nobody has checked in years.

St Peter and St Paul, West Clandon, 1913

In October 1913, fire broke out in the bell tower of the 12th century church at West Clandon, in the grounds of Clandon Park. A report carried as far away as New Zealand described how the spire and belfry burned. Five of the six bells, said to be the first peal in Surrey, were “reduced to a heap of melted metal.”

The fire was thought to be accidental. The evening before, a bell ringer had taken a light up into the belfry to work on the tenor bell.

That detail matters more than it seems. Bell towers are tall, timber-lined, rarely visited and hard to reach. Any work up there involving a flame, a heat gun, a lamp or power tools is a fire risk, and the place where a fire is least likely to be spotted early. Today we’d call that “hot work” and expect it to be controlled with a permit and a fire watch afterwards.

Clandon has a longer fire story too. In 2015, Clandon Park House itself, just across the grounds, was gutted. I’ve written about what the Clandon Park fire teaches owners of historic buildings separately.

St James, Abinger Common, 1944 and 1964

St James’ Church sits high in the Surrey Hills between Dorking and Guildford, and it has been unlucky twice.

Shortly before 8am on Thursday 3 August 1944, a German flying bomb hit the church as the rector was on his way to take communion. The church’s own history lists what came down: the west wall of the nave, the belfry and spire, and the whole nave roof. Remarkably, nobody was hurt. The verger later recalled a tremendous explosion and dust everywhere, but no fire. The church was rebuilt and rededicated by the Bishop of Guildford in May 1951.

Then, in June 1964, during a storm over southern England, lightning struck deep into the base of the spire and set the tower on fire. Firemen were called, and villagers helped carry things out of the church to safety.

Abinger is a reminder that a tall tower on high ground is exposed every time a storm passes. Lightning protection, and keeping it tested, is part of fire safety for buildings like this.

St Mary the Virgin, Putney, 1973

St Mary’s in Putney is famous for one thing above all. In 1647, during the English Civil War, it was where the Putney Debates on the future of the constitution took place.

In June 1973, an arson attack gutted much of the church. Historic England’s listing records that the fire destroyed much of the roof, the galleries and the fittings. The medieval tower survived.

Recovery took almost a decade. The parish moved its worship to nearby churches while St Mary’s was restored and reordered by the architect Ronald Sims between 1980 and 1982. It was finally rehallowed on 6 February 1982, nearly nine years after the fire.

Nine years is worth pausing on. A church isn’t just a building. It’s a place for weddings, funerals, baptisms, concerts, groups and the people who rely on them. When it’s gone, all of that has to find somewhere else to go, often for years.

St Mary’s, Barnes, 1978

Five years later and a mile or so upriver, St Mary’s in Barnes burned on 8 June 1978. The fire destroyed the Victorian and Edwardian parts of the church but left the 15th century tower and the medieval chapel almost intact.

Barnes is one of those stories where something unexpected came out of the loss. During the restoration, the old south wall was exposed and revealed medieval wall paintings. Historic England’s listing still notes fire-blackened paintwork on the east wall and a fire-blackened memorial from the 1660s. The artist John Piper photographed the ruins, and his photographs are now in the Tate Archive.

The architect Edward Cullinan designed the new church around what survived. The old chapel is now called the Langton Chapel, after Stephen Langton, the Archbishop of Canterbury connected with Magna Carta. You can read more about the rebuild on St Mary’s Barnes website, which has scanned its scrapbooks from the years after the fire.

Those photographs and scrapbooks are a good example of something every church should have before a fire, not after. A proper photographic record of the building and its contents is one of the most useful things you can give the people who will one day have to restore it.

St Nicholas, Peper Harow, 2007

Back to Christmas Eve 2007. Get Surrey reported that firefighters were called at 12.08am. Two fire engines from Godalming arrived and immediately asked for four more, followed by an aerial ladder platform. Crews fought the fire until 3.56am.

By then about 80% of the 19th century roof had been destroyed. The tower and nave were gutted, and most of the contents were lost. The chancel and the Midleton chapel escaped with water and soot damage. The vicar, the Rev John Fellows, called the damage “just unbelievable.” He said at the time there were no signs the fire had been started deliberately.

What strikes me most is how the fire was found. Not by an alarm, but by neighbours who happened to wake up. In a small village in the middle of the night, that’s luck, and you can’t plan around luck.

St Nicholas is a Grade II* listed building with an interior by A.W.N. Pugin, one of the great Victorian architects. Purcell, the architects who led the rebuild, kept and restored Pugin’s work in the chancel and repaired as much of the fire-damaged fabric as they could. They also used the rebuild to bring the church up to date, with level access, a small kitchen, an accessible toilet and low-energy heating. The construction value was around £1.4 million.

Two near misses in Guildford, 2013

Not every church fire story ends in ruins. Two from Guildford in 2013 show how quickly a small problem can become a big one, and how it can be stopped.

On Saturday 25 May 2013, St Mary’s Church on Quarry Street, Guildford’s oldest building, was hosting an art exhibition. Someone noticed a smell of burning. A temporary light fitting had collapsed, unnoticed, against a wooden roof beam, and the heat had slowly charred the timber. The Guildford Dragon reported that Surrey Fire and Rescue Service was called at 1.37pm and arrived within ten minutes, with two fire engines from Guildford and a high-level appliance from Chertsey. Damage was minor.

The church’s tower is 10th century Saxon. If that exhibition had closed for the night half an hour earlier, the beam could have smouldered for hours with nobody there.

Later that year, during the service to institute a new rector at St Saviour’s Church in Guildford, the organ caught fire. The diocesan magazine reported that the service carried on in the car park while the emergency services made sure the building was safe.

Temporary lighting and organs come up again and again in church fires. Temporary lights are often fitted for one event and then forgotten. Organs have electric blowers and motors hidden away inside large timber cases. Both deserve a place in your fire risk assessment.

All Saints, Fleet, 2015

Fleet is in Hampshire, but All Saints is in the Diocese of Guildford and only a few miles from Camberley and Farnborough. Its story belongs here.

All Saints was designed by William Burges, one of the most original Victorian architects, and built in 1861 and 1862. Shortly after 5.30pm on Monday 22 June 2015, according to the parish’s own fire diary, a mother taking her daughter to a ballet class in the community centre next door noticed smoke coming from the church. The ballet staff called the fire and rescue service and the children were evacuated. When the first crew arrived at 5.40pm, the church was already burning fiercely.

Hampshire and Isle of Wight Fire and Rescue Service says around 35 firefighters attended, led by the on-call crew from Fleet fire station just around the corner. They saved the brick structure, but the roof and the interior were destroyed. The fire was an arson attack.

The repair bill was estimated at £4.5 million. The National Churches Trust describes how money came in from all over the world, and how people told the parish they had been married or had their children baptised there. Conservators worked to restore Burges’s painted decoration, using analysis of the original paint to match the colours.

All Saints reopened in 2023, eight years after the fire. The Fleet firefighters were invited back for the service of reconsecration.

Arson is the single biggest cause of church fires. Ecclesiastical Insurance, the specialist church insurer, says plainly that arson is the most common cause of fires in churches. Following the Fleet fire, it launched a campaign fronted by Loyd Grossman, then chairman of the Churches Conservation Trust, and reported dealing with 129 arson-related church claims between 2010 and 2015.

What Surrey church fires have in common

Line these Surrey church fires up side by side and the same patterns appear.

They’re found late

Croydon was spotted by the sexton. Peper Harow by neighbours woken in the night. Fleet by a passing parent. Guildford by a visitor’s nose. Not one of them was first detected by an alarm system.

Churches are empty for most of the week and most of every night. A fire that starts at midnight can burn for a long time before anyone notices. Automatic fire detection linked to a monitoring centre, so the alarm reaches someone who will call the fire and rescue service, is one of the most effective protections a church can have.

They start high and spread through the roof

West Clandon started in the belfry. Guildford was a roof beam. Peper Harow, Fleet and Putney all lost their roofs. Church roof spaces are usually large, open and full of old, dry timber, with nothing to stop a fire running from one end to the other.

Modern buildings are divided into fire-resisting compartments to stop fire spreading. That’s called compartmentation, and I’ve explained it in plain English in my fire compartmentation guide. Most historic churches have very little of it, which is why detection and prevention matter so much.

The cause is often ordinary

A light taken into a bell tower. A temporary lamp left against a beam. An organ. Heating flues. Lightning. None of these is exotic. They’re the everyday things a fire risk assessment is meant to pick up.

Recovery takes years

Croydon took three years. Barnes and Putney took several. Fleet took eight. During that time, the life of the parish has to happen somewhere else.

What’s lost often can’t be replaced

Croydon’s medieval charters. West Clandon’s bells. Burges’s decoration at Fleet, which had to be painstakingly recreated. A photographic record kept off site, and a plan for what to save first, can make all the difference.

How to protect your church

Churches and other places of worship come under the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005. That means someone, usually the churchwardens and the parochial church council, is the responsible person, and there must be a suitable and sufficient fire risk assessment.

Here’s what I’d look at first in any historic church.

  • Make sure your fire risk assessment is current and written by someone who understands historic buildings.
  • Consider automatic fire detection with remote monitoring, especially for roof spaces, towers and organ cases.
  • Have the electrical installation inspected regularly, and remove temporary lighting and extension leads after events.
  • Control hot work, such as lead work, paint stripping or anything involving a flame or heat gun, with a written permit and a fire watch afterwards.
  • Have the organ’s electrics checked as part of its regular maintenance.
  • Keep the church locked when nobody’s there, keep bins and combustible rubbish well away from the walls, and report signs of vandalism or small fires straight away.
  • Put out all candles when you lock up, and keep votive candle stands away from curtains and paper.
  • Check whether you need lightning protection, and keep it tested if you have it.
  • Make sure fire engines can reach the building, and know where your nearest hydrant is.
  • Keep a photographic record of the building and its treasures, and store a copy away from the church.
  • Write a salvage plan that says what to save first, who will do it and where it will go.
  • Check your insurance values. Croydon’s in 1867 turned out to be far too low.

Ecclesiastical’s arson guidance for churches has a lot of practical, low-cost advice too. If you’d like to understand salvage planning in more depth, my article on fire safety in historic buildings and what Windsor Castle teaches covers it step by step.

More than a building

It’s easy to read stories like these as stories about buildings. Roofs, timbers, insurance claims. But the people who lived through them rarely talk about it that way.

The community loses its meeting place

When All Saints burned, the parish told the National Churches Trust that people kept stopping to tell them what the church meant to them. They had been married there. Their children had been baptised there. On the parish’s own memories page, one family wrote that a great-grandfather, a stonemason, had made the font.

A church is where a town marks the biggest moments of its life. It’s also the playgroup, the choir, the lunch club, the concert venue and the place people go when something terrible has happened. At Fleet, the fire was spotted by a parent bringing a child to a ballet class next door. At Peper Harow, 150 people had sung carols there only hours before. When the building goes, all of that has to find somewhere else to happen, and some of it never comes back.

History that can’t be rebuilt

You can rebuild a roof. You can’t rebuild the past.

Croydon’s charters had survived almost 600 years before they burned in a single night. The bells of West Clandon, said to be the first peal in Surrey, became a lump of melted metal. At Fleet, William Burges’s painted decoration had to be painstakingly recreated from analysis of the paint that survived. It looks right again, but it’s a careful copy now, not the original.

Ecclesiastical Insurance made the same point after the Fleet fire. Its church operations director warned that because records and original objects are often kept on site, communities can also lose local history, unique objects and ancient records.

Think about what’s in your church right now. Parish registers. War memorials with the names of local families. Monuments, brasses, stained glass, bells, embroidered kneelers made by people long gone. Most of it has no price that means anything, because there’s no second one anywhere in the world.

Insurance doesn’t cover everything

Even a well-insured church can’t buy back what it’s lost. At Fleet, the Building Conservation Directory explains that the insurance would pay to put the church back exactly as it was before the fire, but not, for example, to properly conserve the decoration in the chancel. That had to be found from elsewhere. The parish raised money from all over the world. Some supporters even jumped out of aeroplanes to help.

Insurance pays for bricks, timber and labour. It can’t pay for eight years without your church, or for the people who drift away in that time and don’t come back.

What survives is often what someone planned for

There’s a hopeful thread running through these stories too. At Abinger, villagers helped carry treasures out of the burning church. At Peper Harow, the chancel and the Midleton chapel came through with water and soot damage, which meant Pugin’s work could be kept. At Barnes, the fire exposed medieval wall paintings nobody had seen for centuries, and John Piper’s photographs gave the restorers a record to work from.

The difference between losing everything and saving what matters most is rarely luck. It’s usually a fire that’s found early, a building that slows the fire down, and people who know what to save first and how to do it safely.

That’s what a good fire risk assessment, a working fire alarm and a simple salvage plan give you. Not just a building that’s protected, but a community that still has its church, its history and its treasures when the worst happens.

Getting help

I carry out fire risk assessments for churches and historic buildings across Surrey, from Guildford and Godalming to Camberley, Farnham and Dorking, and into Berkshire and Hampshire. My small in-house team and I don’t subcontract our assessments, and we don’t carry out remedial works, so the advice we give has no strings attached.

If you’re responsible for a church and you’d like to talk about its fire risk assessment, call me on 01276 300351 or email office@esifiresafety.co.uk.

Frequently asked questions

Do churches need a fire risk assessment?

Yes. Places of worship are covered by the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005, so the responsible person must make sure a suitable and sufficient fire risk assessment is carried out and kept under review. For most Church of England churches, that responsibility sits with the churchwardens and the parochial church council.

What causes most Surrey church fires?

In Surrey, as nationally, arson is a major cause. Putney in 1973 and Fleet in 2015 were both arson attacks, and Ecclesiastical Insurance, the specialist church insurer, says arson is the most common cause of fires in churches. Electrical faults, heating, candles, hot work and lightning are other common causes.

Should a church have a fire alarm?

It depends on the building, how it’s used and the outcome of the fire risk assessment. But many of the fires in this article were found late by passers-by. Automatic detection linked to a monitoring centre can raise the alarm when the church is empty, which is when most serious church fires happen.

How long does it take to rebuild a church after a fire?

Often years. Croydon Parish Church took three years to rebuild after 1867. St Mary’s in Putney took nearly nine years after 1973. All Saints in Fleet reopened eight years after the fire in 2015.

What is a church salvage plan?

It’s a written plan that sets out which objects in the church matter most, the order they should be removed in if there’s a fire, who will do it, what equipment they need and where items will be taken. It should be shared with your local fire and rescue service and kept up to date.

What is hot work and why does it matter in churches?

Hot work is any work that involves a flame, sparks or heat, such as lead roofing, soldering, welding, grinding or stripping paint with a heat gun. It’s a common cause of fires in historic buildings, often because a smouldering fire starts after the workers have left. Hot work should be controlled with a written permit, and someone should check the area for some time after the work finishes.

Picture of Jamie Morgan <h5>MIFSM MIFPO MSFPE MIET</h5>

Jamie Morgan

MIFSM MIFPO MSFPE MIET

Jamie Morgan is the founder and Principal Consultant at ESI: Fire Safety. With more than 25 years’ experience across fire safety, electrical engineering and technical compliance, he helps building owners and managers work out what needs attention first and what will work day to day. His work spans fire risk assessments, fire strategies, compliance reviews and DSEAR assessments, backed by hands-on experience designing and implementing life safety systems and electrical safety management.

Growing up around the timber-framed cottages and oast houses of rural Kent gave Jamie a lasting interest in historic and heritage buildings. He brings that interest to his work with churches and listed properties, finding ways to improve fire safety while preserving the features that give them their character.

Jamie holds a Level 6 Diploma in Fire Risk Assessment and a Level 5 qualification in Fire Engineering Design. That combination helps him explain how a building’s design affects fire risk, why a recommendation matters and what it means for the people who use the building. You can check his Intermediate registration on the National Fire Risk Assessors Register.

Jamie keeps up with developments in the profession through his memberships of the Institute of Fire Safety Managers, the Society of Fire Protection Engineers, the Institute of Fire Prevention Officers, the British Fire Services Association and the Institution of Engineering and Technology, which he joined in 2007. He also holds supporter membership of the Institute of Heritage Building Conservation and membership of Society for the Protection of Ancient Buildings.

Tags :

Share :

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Telegram

Related Articles

Speak to a fire safety consultant

Planning a fit-out, need a fire risk assessment or working through a compliance issue?

Bring your plans or questions and we’ll talk through what your project needs.