Should a Fire Risk Assessment Tell Me What Signs and Extinguishers I Need?

Walk round enough buildings and you notice a pattern. Some have far too much. There’s a fire exit sign over the front door everyone uses every day. There’s an extinguisher ID sign above every extinguisher, and three extinguishers in the hallway of a block of flats where nobody has ever been shown how to use one.

Then there’s what’s missing. No fire action notice by the call point. No sign on the side exit that only gets used in an emergency. A powder extinguisher in a small office where it would fill the room with a cloud nobody could see through.

More kit does not mean more safety. That’s why so many people ask me the same question. Should my fire risk assessment tell me what signs and extinguishers I need?

The short answer is yes. A good fire risk assessment should tell you whether what you have is right for your building, and what’s missing. But it isn’t a shopping list, and it shouldn’t read like a sales brochure. This guide explains what the law actually asks for, what your assessment should cover, and where the specialist work begins.

Contents

The short answer

Your fire risk assessment should look at your signs and your firefighting equipment and tell you whether they’re suitable for the building, the people in it and the risks they face. If something is missing, wrong or in the wrong place, it should say so, and it should say what needs to happen next.

What it usually won’t do is give you a detailed specification. It won’t list every sign size and fixing height, or calculate the exact extinguisher ratings floor by floor. That’s design work, and it’s normally done by a competent extinguisher engineer or signage specialist working to the British Standards. Your assessment sets the direction. The specialist fills in the detail.

Think of it this way. The assessment tells you that the rear exit isn’t signed and your kitchen has no fire blanket. It doesn’t need to tell you which supplier to use.

What the law asks for

In England and Wales, the main law is the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005, usually called the Fire Safety Order. It covers almost every building except private homes, including the common parts of blocks of flats and HMOs.

The phrase that matters most is “where necessary”. The government’s guide for people with duties under fire safety law puts it plainly. The Fire Safety Order requires that, where necessary, escape routes and exits must be indicated by signs. It says the same about equipment. Where necessary, premises must be provided with appropriate firefighting equipment.

It goes further on extinguishers. They must be easy to reach and simple to use, and they must be signed if they aren’t easy to see.

So who decides what’s necessary? You do, as the responsible person, through your fire risk assessment. The government’s guide for small non-domestic premises says the fire risk identified in your assessment determines the level of fire protection you need. It also says its own recommendations shouldn’t be treated as rigid standards to follow regardless of the actual risks.

That’s the heart of it. The law doesn’t hand you a fixed list. It asks you to assess your building and provide what it needs.

The safety signs regulations

Workplaces also come under the Health and Safety (Safety Signs and Signals) Regulations 1996. These require safety signs where a risk can’t be avoided or controlled in other ways, and they set out the colours and shapes those signs must use. Signs that follow BS 5499, the British Standard for fire safety signs, will satisfy these regulations as long as they still do their job.

No smoking signs

There’s one sign that isn’t a matter of judgement. Under smoke-free law, enclosed workplaces and public places must display no smoking signs. The government’s small premises guide says at least one must be displayed. Your assessment should check it’s there.

Fire safety signs

Fire safety signs do one simple job. They help people who don’t know the building get out of it, and help people find what they need in a hurry. Here are the main kinds you’ll come across.

Fire exit and escape route signs

These are the familiar green signs with a running figure and an arrow. They point people along the escape route to a final exit. They matter most in buildings where visitors, customers or new staff won’t know their way around, and on routes that aren’t used every day.

You don’t always need them. In a small building with a single exit that everyone uses all the time, the government’s small premises guide says it shouldn’t normally be necessary to sign that exit. Where there are alternative exits, signs may be needed for routes people don’t use regularly, especially if the way to them isn’t obvious.

Signs should follow BS 5499-4, which covers escape route signing, and use the pictograms in BS EN ISO 7010. If your building has a mix of old-style signs and newer ones, it’s worth putting right. Mixing styles can confuse people at exactly the wrong moment.

Escape route signs also need to be visible when the lights go out. That’s the job of emergency lighting, which should light up exit signs and the route itself.

Fire action notices

A fire action notice tells people what to do if they discover a fire or hear the alarm. It usually covers raising the alarm, calling the fire and rescue service, leaving the building and where to assemble.

The government’s guide says it is normally necessary to display fire procedure notices, and that in a building with a fire alarm they should be placed near each break-glass call point. In my experience this is one of the most commonly missing signs, and one of the cheapest to fix.

A fire action notice should match your actual procedure. A generic notice that says “assemble at the front car park” is worse than useless if your assembly point is round the back. Blocks of flats with a stay put policy need notices that say so clearly.

Fire door signs

Fire doors only work when they’re shut. “Fire door keep shut” signs remind people not to wedge them open. The government’s guide says self-closing fire doors should be marked to say they must be kept shut. Doors to cupboards, risers and plant rooms that should stay locked get “Fire door keep locked” signs instead. Doors held open on magnetic hold-open devices, which release when the alarm sounds, get “Automatic fire door keep clear” signs.

Firefighting equipment signs

These show where extinguishers, fire blankets, hose reels and alarm call points are. The government’s guide describes signing essential firefighting equipment as good practice. Where equipment isn’t readily visible, the law requires it to be signed.

Signs for firefighters

In residential buildings over 18 metres tall, the Fire Safety (England) Regulations 2022 require wayfinding signs that show floor numbers and flat numbers, so firefighters can find their way in smoke. Those signs are for the fire and rescue service, not residents, but your assessment for a taller block should check they’re in place.

Do I need a sign above every extinguisher?

This is one of the most common questions I’m asked, and one where you’ll hear very different answers depending on who you ask.

Some sign suppliers say extinguisher ID signs are mandatory in every building. The picture is more nuanced than that.

The legal requirement is that firefighting equipment is easy to find and identify. The safety signs regulations require red as the identifying colour for firefighting equipment, and if the equipment itself is red, that satisfies the requirement. An extinguisher that’s red, mounted in an obvious place and clearly labelled on its body may already do the job.

That doesn’t mean ID signs are pointless. They tell people at a glance which extinguisher is right for which fire, and using the wrong one can make a fire worse. Where extinguishers sit behind a door, round a corner, inside a cabinet or in a busy space, a location sign is needed. In many workplaces ID signs are simply good practice.

So the honest answer is that it depends on the building. Your fire risk assessment should look at whether people can find and identify your extinguishers quickly. If they can’t, it should say what’s needed.

Fire extinguishers

A portable fire extinguisher is for tackling a very small fire in its earliest stage, if it’s safe to do so. It isn’t a way of fighting a fire that’s taken hold. If there’s any doubt, the right thing to do is raise the alarm and get out.

Fire classes in plain English

Extinguishers are matched to what’s burning. The British Standards use fire classes, which sound technical but are simple once explained.

  • Class A fires involve ordinary solid materials, such as paper, wood, card, fabric and many plastics. This is what most offices, shops and homes are full of.
  • Class B fires involve flammable liquids, such as petrol, diesel, solvents and paint.
  • Class C fires involve flammable gases, such as LPG or natural gas.
  • Class D fires involve burning metals, such as magnesium. These are rare outside specialist industry.
  • Class F fires involve cooking oils and fats, such as a chip pan or deep fat fryer.

Electrical equipment isn’t a class of its own. It’s treated as a separate hazard, because the risk is getting an electric shock from the extinguisher’s discharge. Once the power is off, the fire is usually a Class A fire.

The main types

Water extinguishers are for Class A fires. Foam extinguishers cover Class A and many Class B fires. Carbon dioxide (CO2) extinguishers are mainly used on electrical equipment, because they leave no residue. Wet chemical extinguishers are designed for Class F cooking oil fires. Dry powder extinguishers cover several classes, but the cloud they produce can make it hard to see and breathe, which is why BS 5306-8 gives guidance on using powder indoors.

For most small premises, the government’s guide suggests a water-based extinguisher on each floor, possibly with a CO2 extinguisher alongside, will be adequate. Where cooking involves fat fryers, it says a fire blanket and a Class F extinguisher should be provided in the kitchen.

A fire blanket is a sheet of fire-resisting material that you lay over a small pan fire to smother it. It’s often the simplest and safest piece of kit in a kitchen.

How many extinguishers do I need?

The British Standard for choosing and positioning extinguishers is BS 5306-8. A fully revised version, BS 5306-8:2023, came into effect on 30 November 2023 and replaced the 2012 version. The changes include clarified recommendations for Class A hazards, changes for Class C hazards, revised travel distances and new information on batteries.

For Class A fires, the standard works on a combined minimum fire rating of 0.065 multiplied by the floor area of the storey in square metres. Extinguishers carry a fire rating, such as 13A, which shows the size of test fire they can put out. A standard 9 litre water extinguisher is assumed to achieve a 13A rating.

Here’s how that works in practice. A 400 square metre office floor needs a combined rating of 26A, which two 13A water extinguishers would provide. The standard then sets out how far anyone should have to travel to reach an extinguisher, and where extinguishers should be placed. They usually go on escape routes and by exits, so people can grab one on their way out and still have a way out behind them.

The 2023 revision changed the travel distances, so if your extinguishers were positioned years ago, they may not match the current recommendations. That’s something your extinguisher engineer should check.

Your fire risk assessment should tell you if your coverage looks inadequate for the risks. The detailed calculation is normally the engineer’s job.

Blocks of flats and HMOs

Residential buildings are where I see the most confusion.

Purpose-built blocks of flats

Most purpose-built blocks are designed so that each flat is its own fire-resisting box, and the common parts are kept clear and protected. In a block like that, the national guidance says there is no requirement for fire extinguishers in the common parts, except in plant and service rooms.

There’s a good reason. Extinguishers in a common corridor tempt untrained residents to stay and fight a fire when they should be getting out or staying safe behind their own front door. They also get stolen, set off and misused. If your block has extinguishers in the common parts, your assessment may well recommend removing them.

The protection in a block of flats comes from the building itself. That means fire doors, compartmentation and a protected escape route. If you want to understand how that works, my fire compartmentation guide explains it in plain English.

Signs in flats are usually simpler too. You’ll need fire door signs, a fire action notice that explains your evacuation strategy, and directional signs where the route out isn’t obvious.

HMOs

Houses in multiple occupation are a little different. The LACORS housing fire safety guidance, which most councils use, generally recommends a fire blanket in each shared kitchen. Some councils no longer expect extinguishers in smaller HMOs, because tenants are rarely trained to use them. Larger HMOs, and your local council’s licensing conditions, may say otherwise, so it’s always worth checking.

Lithium-ion batteries

E-bikes, e-scooters, mobility scooters, power tools and battery storage are now part of everyday life, and they bring a different kind of fire risk. The 2023 revision of BS 5306-8 includes information on batteries for the first time.

Here’s the honest picture. A lithium-ion battery that goes into “thermal runaway”, where the cells overheat and feed their own fire, is very difficult to put out with a portable extinguisher. It can reignite after it seems to be out. The answer is mostly prevention: where batteries are charged, what they’re charged with, and keeping charging away from escape routes.

Your fire risk assessment should look at where batteries are stored and charged in your building. If e-bikes are being charged in a communal hallway, that’s a far bigger issue than which extinguisher sits beside them.

Checks, servicing and training

Extinguishers that are never checked are a false comfort. The government’s small premises guide sets out a simple routine. Carry out a visual check of all extinguishers every month, and have them inspected and tested by a competent contractor every year.

The monthly check is something you or a member of staff can do. Is each extinguisher in its place? Is the pressure gauge in the green, where there is one? Is the safety pin and tamper seal intact? Is it damaged? Can people get to it?

The annual service is done to BS 5306-3. Under the current standards, the engineer should also review whether your extinguisher cover is still right for the building, particularly after a change of use or a new hazard.

Training matters just as much as the kit. The government’s guide says a sufficient number of staff should be nominated and trained to use extinguishers where your fire procedures include them. Staff also need to know when not to tackle a fire. If in doubt, raise the alarm and get out.

What your fire risk assessment should say

When you read your fire risk assessment, the section on signs and equipment should answer these questions in plain English.

  • Are escape routes and exits signed where they need to be?
  • Are the signs in the right places, consistent in style and lit by emergency lighting?
  • Is there a fire action notice by each call point, and does it match your real procedure?
  • Are fire doors marked correctly?
  • Is the no smoking sign displayed?
  • Is there suitable firefighting equipment for the risks in each area, including kitchens, plant rooms and anywhere flammable liquids or gases are kept?
  • Can people find, reach and identify the equipment quickly?
  • Is any equipment in the wrong place, the wrong type, or there when it shouldn’t be?
  • Is there evidence of monthly checks and an annual service?
  • Have staff been trained, and do they know when not to use an extinguisher?

Every problem it finds should appear in the action plan, with a priority and a clear description of what needs doing. “Signage inadequate” is not enough. “Provide escape route signs on the first floor corridor leading to the rear stair, as visitors cannot see the alternative exit” is something you can act on.

Why it matters who tells you

Here’s something worth thinking about. If the person assessing your building also sells extinguishers and signs, there’s an obvious temptation to recommend more of them.

That doesn’t mean everyone who does both is dishonest. But you’re entitled to advice with no strings attached. At ESI, my small in-house team and I don’t sell, supply or service extinguishers or signs, and we don’t carry out remedial works. We don’t subcontract our assessments either. So when I tell you that you need a fire action notice, or that three extinguishers in your hallway should come out, there’s nothing in it for me except getting the answer right.

Sometimes that means telling you that you need more. Quite often it means telling you that you need less, in better places.

If you’d like a fire risk assessment for a building in Surrey, Berkshire, Hampshire or the surrounding counties, or a second opinion on what you’ve been told, call me on 01276 300351 or email office@esifiresafety.co.uk.

Frequently asked questions

Is it a legal requirement to have fire extinguishers?

The Fire Safety Order requires appropriate firefighting equipment where it’s necessary. Most workplaces will need at least some. The government’s guidance says it will normally be necessary to provide an adequate number of appropriate extinguishers. But there are buildings, such as the common parts of most purpose-built blocks of flats, where guidance says extinguishers aren’t needed at all. Your fire risk assessment decides what’s necessary for your building.

Does my fire risk assessor have to tell me how many extinguishers to buy?

Your assessor should tell you whether your current provision looks suitable and what’s missing. In simple premises they may say exactly what’s needed, such as a water extinguisher on each floor and a fire blanket in the kitchen. In larger or more complex buildings, the detailed calculation to BS 5306-8 is normally done by a competent extinguisher engineer.

Are fire exit signs a legal requirement?

Escape routes and exits must be signed where necessary. In a small building with one exit that everyone uses every day, signs may not be needed at all. In larger buildings, or where alternative exits aren’t obvious, they will be. Your fire risk assessment should say which applies.

Do I need an ID sign above every fire extinguisher?

Not in every case. The law requires equipment to be easy to find and identify, and signed if it isn’t readily visible. ID signs are widely used as good practice because they help people choose the right extinguisher quickly. Your assessment should check whether people can find and identify your extinguishers in a hurry.

What is a fire action notice?

It’s a notice that tells people what to do if there’s a fire, including how to raise the alarm, how to call the fire and rescue service, how to leave and where to assemble. Government guidance says they’re normally necessary, and in buildings with a fire alarm they should be placed near each call point.

How often should fire extinguishers be checked?

Visually, every month, which you can do yourself. Every year, they should be inspected and tested by a competent contractor to BS 5306-3.

Should there be fire extinguishers in the hallway of a block of flats?

Usually not. National guidance says there’s no requirement for extinguishers in the common parts of purpose-built blocks, except in plant and service rooms. Residents should get out, or stay put behind their own front door if that’s the strategy, rather than stop to fight a fire.

Has the fire extinguisher standard changed recently?

Yes. BS 5306-8:2023 came into effect on 30 November 2023 and replaced the 2012 version. It changed travel distances and the recommendations for Class A and Class C fires, and added information on batteries. If your extinguishers were planned under the old standard, ask your engineer to review the cover at the next annual service.

Who is responsible for signs and extinguishers?

The responsible person under the Fire Safety Order. That’s usually the employer, the owner or whoever has control of the premises. In a block of flats, it’s normally the freeholder or managing agent for the common parts. You can appoint someone competent to help, but the legal duty stays with you.

Picture of Jamie Morgan <h5>MIFSM MIFPO MSFPE MIET</h5>

Jamie Morgan

MIFSM MIFPO MSFPE MIET

Jamie Morgan is the founder and Principal Consultant at ESI: Fire Safety. With more than 25 years’ experience across fire safety, electrical engineering and technical compliance, he helps building owners and managers work out what needs attention first and what will work day to day. His work spans fire risk assessments, fire strategies, compliance reviews and DSEAR assessments, backed by hands-on experience designing and implementing life safety systems and electrical safety management.

Growing up around the timber-framed cottages and oast houses of rural Kent gave Jamie a lasting interest in historic and heritage buildings. He brings that interest to his work with churches and listed properties, finding ways to improve fire safety while preserving the features that give them their character.

Jamie holds a Level 6 Diploma in Fire Risk Assessment and a Level 5 qualification in Fire Engineering Design. That combination helps him explain how a building’s design affects fire risk, why a recommendation matters and what it means for the people who use the building. You can check his Intermediate registration on the National Fire Risk Assessors Register.

Jamie keeps up with developments in the profession through his memberships of the Institute of Fire Safety Managers, the Society of Fire Protection Engineers, the Institute of Fire Prevention Officers, the British Fire Services Association and the Institution of Engineering and Technology, which he joined in 2007. He also holds supporter membership of the Institute of Heritage Building Conservation and membership of Society for the Protection of Ancient Buildings.

Tags :

Share :

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Telegram

Related Articles

Speak to a fire safety consultant

Planning a fit-out, need a fire risk assessment or working through a compliance issue?

Bring your plans or questions and we’ll talk through what your project needs.